Everybody’s Mom
We explore why we care so much about the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie.
By Jesse McKinley, Feb. 15, 2026, 7:36 a.m. ET
You’re reading The Morning newsletter. Your daily guide to understanding what’s happening — and why it matters. Hosted by Sam Sifton, for readers in the U.S. and Canada.
My mom is 89, and her daily life is rough: She can’t travel, she can’t cook, she needs help in the bathroom. Still, her mind is still there, as is her thirst for the world outside. Her television is almost constantly on, invariably tuned to cable news.
For the past two weeks, that means a lot of coverage of the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, a nonstop wash of on-the-scene reports, experts (and amateurs) who spin theories and parse tips, and beaming photos of the victim playing mahjong in happier times.
True crime stories have long galvanized the public and dominated tabloids and podcasts, and the search for Guthrie since she was apparently abducted on Feb. 1 has firmly grabbed the attention of the American public. For me and many others in Gen X, this one resonates especially because we are caring for our own aging parents. Nancy, who is five years younger than my mother, has trouble walking, depends on medication, but is said to be “sharp as a tack.” Same and same and same.
Of course, interest is also heightened because Guthrie’s youngest daughter, Savannah, has one of the best-known (and best-loved) faces in the media as a co-host of “Today,” the NBC morning show. Still, that frisson and fusion of celebrity and anxiety does not fully explain the way this story has broken through. So I spent the last few days talking to experts, colleagues, friends and, yes, Mom, trying to unpack the other elements.
The facts in the case are spare: Guthrie disappeared just hours after a dinner out with her other daughter, Annie, and son-in law, who dropped her off at home outside Tucson, Ariz. The authorities found blood at the scene. There are purported ransom notes, one demanding $6 million. A video showed a masked man lurking near her front door. This weekend, law enforcement shut down a street and swarmed a parking lot about two miles from Guthrie’s house to search a Range Rover and a residence.
But no suspects have been named.
What might be fueling the fascination is the simple power of an unsolved mystery. Historians, after all, are still looking at cases like the lost colony of Roanoke and the Lindbergh baby. And now there are legions of internet sleuths jumping in, combing over maps of local terrain, possible escape routes and other recent calls to Tucson-area police agencies.
Maybe this crime feels especially terrifying because it shatters our intrinsic sense of the safety of home. It taps into our innate sympathy for vulnerable victims, like children and older people. The fact that many of us feel a profound parasocial bond to famous people like Savannah has been intensified by the raw, wrenching videos she and her siblings have made pleading for help and mercy.
Editor’s Note: AI created the featured image at the top, “Everybody’s Mom.”
Continue/Read Original Article Here: Everybody’s Mom – The New York Times
Discover more from DrWeb's Domain
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
