Home Blog Page 12

In Nvidia CEO alleged China spy affair, plenty of blame to go around – CNBC

0

Read MoreEducation · Subscribe. Join IC. PRO · Pro News · Josh Brown … American intelligence officials reportedly believe she was recruited by China’s Ministry … 

The Housing Precipice: Mapping the Unprecedented VA Mortgage Crisis – DrWeb’s Domain – DWD – DWD Editorial

The Housing Precipice: Mapping the Unprecedented VA Mortgage Crisis

Editor’s Note: Let me acknowledge the vital research I located that allowed me to pull the pieces into focus. I could not have done this research or article with the major vetted assistance from the AIs of Gemini and Claude. They dug, I reviewed all of it and we fact-checked at the finish. Thank you for the tools and skills you offered. AIs make mistakes. I reviewed and edited their work shared below. –DrWeb

My story is part of this. I am a veteran, USAF, 1965-1969, and this bureaucratic nightmare hits me personally. I wrote the editorial post to open the story up widely to major and social media and the VA to alert them to how their own failures, and acts finally by Congress (public law), put us right now in crisis mode. Veterans are losing their homes now, record numbers. The Partial Claim Program is not yet available to providers or veterans until Nov 28, 2026. Meanwhile, daily, veterans are being foreclosed leading to increased veteran homelessness in the Nation. I asked Gemini and Claude both to fact-check my editorial, and the majority of items are fully verified. I understand that some data here may be more speculative, or projections, but I publish still, knowing the core is verified. Let me know in comments any flaws or wrong verified information, and I will take corrective actions. I hope this helps veterans, and me personally. We shall see. —DrWeb

For decades, the promise made to those who wear the uniform was simple and sacred: keep your part of the bargain, and the nation will back your right to a stable home. Today, that foundational contract is fraying at an alarming rate. We are witnessing an unprecedented structural crisis across the Department of Veterans Affairs home loan guarantee system—a quiet, bureaucratic catastrophe pushing tens of thousands of American veterans toward the agonizing triad of default, bankruptcy, and homelessness. It is time to pull back the curtain on why this is happening and what can be done right now. Mostly, except for NPR, no major media or social media sources are covering these events, and alerting veterans to these home mortgage “deadlines” or become homeless or worse.

My widely distributed post will be shared via email, the Internet, and social media will help correct the awareness of this crisis. It will be sent to the VA’s head, Doug Collins, the Press Office/Media Affairs office -so they become aware of this major ‘hidden’ crisis. –DrWeb

Part I: Genesis — Where Did This Come From and When Did It Start?

To understand how veterans found themselves on the edge of foreclosure, we must trace the timeline back to the convergence of pandemic-era policy and subsequent monetary shockwaves. When COVID-19 struck, Congress and federal agencies instituted emergency protections, allowing veterans with VA-backed mortgages to enter forbearance and pause payments under the CARES Act.

To help them recover, the VA implemented the COVID-19 Partial Claim Payment Program (July 27, 2021 to October 28, 2022), which let missed payments be moved to the back of the loan at zero interest, letting families resume their original monthly payments at historic interest rates (often 2.5% to 3.5%).

The trap sprang shut in October 2022, when the VA let its COVID-era partial claim option expire on October 28. FHA borrowers kept a permanent partial claim, and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac borrowers kept payment deferral (both set missed payments aside to be repaid at payoff, sale or refinance), but the VA was left without a standalone partial claim. A COVID-19 Refund Modification, which combined a partial claim with a loan modification, remained available until May 31, 2024, and the VA Servicing Purchase Program (VASP) ran from May 31, 2024 until the VA shut it down on May 1, 2025, rolling missed payments into a new loan at a 2.5% interest rate. With those options gone, a traditional loan modification became servicers’ primary tool for most veterans.

Infographic titled “The Housing Precipice” illustrating a 2026 VA mortgage crisis, from pre-crisis growth through collapsing home values and veteran displacement to post-2026 policy responses.

Part II: Not Well Known — Why Isn’t This Headline Daily News?

If nearly 100,000 veteran families are delinquent or facing foreclosure, why isn’t this leading every nightly broadcast? The silence stems from a dangerous confluence of bureaucratic complexity and media optics.

  1. The Conflation Confusion: Mainstream outlets frequently confuse VA loan administration with VA healthcare and disability claims. The two are separate: the 2022 PACT Act expanded health care and benefits for veterans exposed to toxic substances, and the VA hired heavily in the years after its passage to handle the new claims. That surge has since reversed: the VA announced in July 2025 that it would cut nearly 30,000 positions by the end of fiscal 2025, mostly through attrition and voluntary departures rather than layoffs (Federal News Network). Headlines about VA staffing and PACT Act benefits can leave casual observers with the impression that the agency’s problems are being handled elsewhere, masking the mortgage servicing collapse.
  2. Private Servicer Insulation: Unlike direct government loans, VA-backed mortgages are originated and serviced by private commercial entities. Foreclosures filter through private legal channels and state dockets rather than direct federal announcements, diffusing accountability.
  3. The “Invisible” Demographic: A significant portion of the impacted population consists of veterans living on fixed retirements or Social Security. They are less likely to broadcast financial distress on public digital forums, suffering in silence behind closed suburban doors in states across the Sun Belt, like Texas and Florida. IF and when the VA finally checks the data, they find the “lost” seeing the crisis in time, or as it was unfolding. In late 2026, the crisis is likely getting worse. No one knows yet because no one is really paying attention to this “hidden” crisis.

Loan Category (Q2 2026)Seasonally Adjusted Delinquency RatePrimary Structural Risk Factor
VA Loans4.89%Historical lack of permanent partial-claim tool during rate hikes; servicing gaps.
FHA Loans11.79%Lower initial down-payment thresholds and credit tiers.
Conventional Loans2.72%Stronger underwriting standards and long-standing payment-deferral options.

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) National Delinquency Survey, Q2 2026 (released August 13, 2026), seasonally adjusted; loans in forbearance are reported as delinquent. Q1 2026 figures were VA 4.99%, FHA 11.88%, conventional 2.75%.

Part III: The Story Now — November 2026 Landscape

We enter late November 2026 at a critical crossroads. The human toll during the policy gap—the period after VASP (Veterans Affairs Servicing Purchase) shuttered in May 2025 and before the new Partial Claim program took effect—was severe.

The Veterans Foreclosure Crisis project reports that Sen. Richard Blumenthal stated at the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee’s May 20, 2026 hearing that more than 15,000 veterans had lost their homes since VASP ended, and that on September 16, 2026, Rep. Mark Takano said the VA had informed the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee of more than 15,000 veteran foreclosures, while describing his side’s own estimate as more than 17,000. At a committee-minority roundtable that same day, Mike Calhoun of the Center for Responsible Lending estimated 22,000 to 30,000 foreclosures over the preceding 18 months (unverified but noted).

NPR reported in April 2026 that more than 10,000 veterans lost their homes to foreclosure sales after VASP ended. NPR and housing data analysts have consistently tracked roughly 90,000 to 100,000 VA borrowers trapped behind in delinquencies or active foreclosure pipelines.



Part IV: Action Plan — What Can Veterans Do Right Now?

If you or a veteran you know is facing distress on a VA-backed mortgage, remember this fundamental truth: this crisis is structural, not your fault. Affordability is everything, and immediate intervention can halt foreclosure. Utilize the following verified resources and escape routes, ask for help in finding out how to address your issues.

  • Invoke Your Rights Under the New Partial Claim: Insist that your servicer evaluate you under the active VA Partial Claim guidelines rather than forcing a high-rate modification. Ask whether you qualify for the partial claim to cover your missed payments.
  • Contact Your Servicer’s Loss Mitigation Department Immediately: Do not ignore letters or phone calls. Demand escalation to a supervisor who understands VA-specific waterfall guidelines.
  • Engage Veteran Advocacy Hotlines:
    • Veterans United Client Advocate Team (for Veterans United customers; Mon–Fri, 9 a.m.–5 p.m. Central): 1-800-212-5200
    • VA Loan Guaranty Service (VA loan technicians; Mon–Fri, 8 a.m.–6 p.m. ET): 1-877-827-3702 (Select Option 6)
    • MyVA411 (general VA information line, 24/7): 800-698-2411. VA Benefits Hotline: 800-827-1000. Home loan information: benefits.va.gov/HOMELOANS.
  • Immediate Crisis Support: If financial pressure is causing acute emotional distress or crisis, call or text 988 and press 1 (available 24/7).
  • Legal and Counseling Aid: Connect with HUD-approved housing counseling agencies or legal aid groups specializing in military and veteran housing defense to invoke state-specific mediation and foreclosure protection programs.

See Also and Bibliography


See Also & Bibliography


Susan Glasser: POTUS’s Desperate Fight to Regain Leverage

0

Read More

Trump’s loyalist foot soldiers in Congress are still sticking by him but the power of the presidency is ebbing away from him. He’s lost not only the leverage to broker a peace between Russia and Ukraine, the Iranians also saw the results of the midterms—which significantly undercuts Trump’s ability to negotiate a deal favorable to the US. Plus: Vance’s political future is evaporating before our eyes, Thune has been the weakest majority leader in decades, and Trump was clearly living in a delusionary bubble before the midterms (with the help of his giggling assistant).

Susan Glasser joins Tim Miller.

Leave a comment

show notes:

As always: Watch, listen, hit the like button or leave a comment. We want to hear from you.

Ad-free editions of The Bulwark Daily are available exclusively for Bulwark+ members.

Tim Miller’s Bulwark Daily is available wherever you get podcasts and on YouTube. New shows drop each weekday afternoon. If you like the show, leave a comment and ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ wherever you listen.

Share

Add The Bulwark Daily to your player of choice, here.


Read more

 

Were there ‘lost cosmonauts’ in the early Soviet space program?

0

Read More

In the final weeks of 1960, two young radio enthusiasts were monitoring transmissions from a home-built listening station on a rooftop in Turin, Italy, when the brothers detected something extraordinary: a faint signal that bore the hallmarks of one originating from space. That wasn’t the only surprising thing about the alleged signal:, the transmission carried a very familiar message: it was Morse code for the international distress signal SOS.

As the youths listened, the signal seemed to grow weaker. This raised a troubling possibility: could it be that the signal’s source was moving farther away from Earth? And if so, was it possible that this concerning signal was of Soviet origin — perhaps a spacecraft drifting helplessly into space, carrying a cosmonaut on board whose doomed mission had never been publicly acknowledged?

These strange events from November 1960 became the first in a series of alleged radio signal interceptions that would form the basis of an enduring Cold War-era mystery involving so-called “lost cosmonauts” — early Soviet space travelers rumored to have died during secret spaceflight missions before Yuri Gagarin’s historic flight the following spring, in April 1961.Today, more than six decades later, the story remains one of the most haunting legends of the Space Age. Were there truly early Soviet space missions — with tragically ill-fated cosmonaut crews — that remain undisclosed to this day?

Interception at Torre Bert

The peculiar story began in October 1957, as the Italian brothers Achille and Gian Battista Judica-Cordiglia learned, along with the rest of the world, about the Soviet Union’s successful launch of Sputnik 1, Earth’s first artificial satellite.

Immediately, the two became fascinated with the idea of trying to listen in on signals from such spacecraft and began working to assemble their very own radio tracking station, which they put together mostly from secondhand military surplus equipment. What they couldn’t easily find and purchase, the brothers would often assemble themselves. They built an improvised tracking station in an abandoned World War Two bunker, which the brothers dubbed Torre Bert, that eventually became a fully functional radio facility with an antenna they built from salvaged materials like chicken wire and scraps of metal.

The Judica-Cordiglia brothers, Achille (left) and Giovanni Battista (right). (Image credit: Public domain)

Whatever it lacked in aesthetics, the station made up for in functionality, and soon the brothers’ amateur efforts reportedly allowed them to successfully intercept transmissions associated with Sputnik 2, the first Soviet spacecraft to carry a living creature into orbit: a dog named Laika, who became a one-way passenger on the mission. Later, the boys also said they were able to track transmissions from America’s Explorer 1 satellite.

Some of what the Judica-Cordiglia brothers were able to achieve could be chalked up to being in the right place at the right time. Specifically, their location in northern Italy was advantageous, since it allowed them to monitor signals from Soviet spacecraft passing overhead.

A distress call from space

By late November 1960, the Judica-Cordiglia brothers learned of reports from a West German observatory suggesting there may have been an unidentified satellite in orbit, raising an intriguing possibility: could there have been a spacecraft launch that had not been disclosed to the public?

Intrigued, the brothers began spending their evenings at Torre Bert scanning the skies for radio frequencies in search of the alleged mystery object. Eventually, they claimed to have detected a signal that differed significantly from those they had tracked in the past. Unlike the familiar electronic beeps they had intercepted from other satellites, this transmission seemed unmistakable: it was Morse code for SOS.

According to their account, as the pair listened to the alarming transmission, the signal gradually began to fade, raising a disconcerting possibility: what if the spacecraft they were monitoring hadn’t merely been traveling through orbit, but had been drifting away from Earth?

a person in a red space suit holds up a hammer and sickle in front of four lines that extend upward into space

Soviet Communist Party artwork celebrating the first four Vostok missions, the first human spaceflights in history. (Image credit: Pierce Archive LLC/Buyenlarge via Getty Images)

If correct, the implications were staggering: the Soviet Union may have launched a secret space mission, but this time with a human cosmonaut on board — and something had gone terribly wrong, ending with a spacecraft and its occupant becoming lost in space.

Significantly, the brothers appear to have reached this conclusion independently, and no verified evidence has ever surfaced establishing that the transmission they claimed to have intercepted originated from a crewed spacecraft, let alone one associated with an unacknowledged Soviet mission that somehow escaped Earth’s gravitational influence, with tragic results.

Nonetheless, the brothers’ claims would soon help give rise to a disturbing possibility: that there had been unknown “lost” cosmonauts who perished during missions that remained hidden from public knowledge.

Heartbeats and ghostly voices

The alleged distress signal was only the beginning of a series of unsubstantiated claims the Judica-Cordiglia brothers made, and by the first days of February 1961, the amateur radio sleuths would claim to have intercepted another odd signal. This time, the pair claimed to have heard labored breathing coming across the airwaves, and even what resembled the strained moans of a person aboard an orbiting spacecraft.

In an equally eerie recording the brothers produced, what sounded like a rapidly beating human heart could be heard. The brothers shared the recording with Italian cardiologist Achille Dogliotti, whose examination reportedly led him to conclude that the sounds were consistent with strained breathing and an elevated human heartbeat.

With time, more recordings would begin to appear, featuring transmissions the boys believed to be evidence of unsuccessful Soviet missions that preceded the successful spaceflight of Yuri Gagarin, whose 108-minute journey around Earth in 1961 made him the first human to travel into space.

However, what may be the brothers’ most controversial claim involved a recording they believed captured the final moments of a female cosmonaut whose ill-fated journey allegedly occurred prior to the historic 1963 spaceflight of Valentina Tereshkova, the first woman to travel into space. However, experts have pointed out that these transmissions do not follow typical military communications protocols, further casting doubt on their legitimacy.

a man smiles while wearing a spacesuit with full helmet and visor

Major Yuri Gagarin, the first human to fly into space. (Image credit: Bettmann/Getty Images)

Alleged Soviet surveillance?

As the Judica-Cordiglia brothers’ notoriety increased, journalists and curiosity-seekers weren’t the only ones whose attention they reportedly began to attract; their activities also allegedly garnered interest from intelligence officials.

In one instance, the brothers claimed a man identifying himself as a Russian reporter had visited them. Shortly thereafter, another individual — this time claiming to be an Italian counterintelligence agent — warned them that the “journalist” who had come to see them was a KGB agent.

The Judica-Cordiglias and their unconventional hobby, it seemed, had now placed them in the crosshairs of Soviet intelligence officials.

An unusual twist in this part of the Italian brothers’ story would eventually emerge decades later, when London-based journalist Kris Hollington began reinvestigating their claims for a feature story that appeared in the paranormal-focused magazine Fortean Times. According to Hollington, a former Soviet KGB operative who later served as a Russian ambassador to a European country had reportedly confirmed (on condition of anonymity) that Moscow was indeed interested in the Judica-Cordiglias and their claims.

“Our cosmonauts were warned to be careful what they said while in space after this and we had the brothers followed,” the former KGB agent reportedly told Hollington.

Things could have ended tragically for the brothers if it were not for the fame they achieved at the time for their alleged radio interceptions. As the former KGB agent told Hollington, it was believed for a time that the brothers “had to be dealt with — an accident perhaps,” although after they appeared on a television program that brought them significant attention, any Soviet plans that would have endangered the brothers became impractical.

“That saved their lives,” the former KGB agent reportedly told Hollington, who expressed gratitude for the circumstances that may well have saved the Italian brothers, with the former agent confiding to Hollington that he thought “they were good kids.”

a mannequin in an orange spacesuit reclines in a flight seat in a museum

The Vostok VZA ejection seat and SK-1 space suit, as used in the Soviet Union’s first five Vostok missions in 1961, are displayed in London on Sept. 17, 2015. (Image credit: LEON NEAL/AFP via Getty Images)

Unanswered questions

Of course, the claims of alleged Soviet surveillance are difficult to verify given the anonymity requested by Hollington’s source. The same must be said of many of the claims made by the Judica-Cordiglias — even if the brothers were successful in intercepting Soviet transmissions at the time, that alone does not prove that they uncovered evidence of unacknowledged missions during which cosmonauts may have perished.

Some, like spaceflight researcher Sven Grahn, have acknowledged the genuine tracking capabilities the brothers possessed while remaining skeptical of the more sensational “lost cosmonaut” claims, suggesting the brothers might have misinterpreted some of the transmissions they recorded.

“I think that the Judica-Cordiglia brothers did run a tracking station and picked up signals from various spacecraft,” Grahn said in an assessment of the brothers and their claims. “However, for some reason they thought that they needed sensational stories [to] maintain their image of a ‘hot-shot’ operation,” he adds. “Once they over-interpreted some receptions and made fantastic claims they were ‘trapped’ and had to continue to produce sensations.”

There is also the possibility that the recordings were hoaxes, of course. Whatever the case, there are no independently verified launch records, authenticated communications, or other evidence from the period that provides additional support for what the brothers claimed to have intercepted.

Something that can be verified, however, is the Soviet Union’s well-documented secrecy, adding a further layer of complication to matters. As space historian James Oberg has observed, there are verified instances in which Soviet officials altered photographs and records from the early years of human spaceflight, a fact that has perhaps helped fuel rumors about alleged missing cosmonauts. It is also known that the Soviet space program covered up several deadly disasters, such as a launch pad explosion on Oct. 24, 1960 that killed a high-ranking Soviet military officer and at least 100 others. At the time, Soviet state news outlets reported it as a plane crash.

No verified evidence has emerged to support claims of failed, unacknowledged Soviet crewed spaceflights of the kind described in the lost-cosmonaut legends. Yet the Judica-Cordiglia brothers’ accounts have drawn attention for decades and remain among the strangest stories in the lore of the early Space Age — a fact that illustrates humanity’s enduring fascination with Cold War mysteries and phenomena that exist beyond Earth.

 

ALSC Updates galore!

Read More

Hello members! It has been a bit since I have updated, but there is a lot going on at ALSC.

Town Hall

ALSC will host a Town Hall on Thursday, November 12, at 3 p.m. (CT) via Zoom. We’ll share an update on recent reunification activity and the results of the reunification member-leader survey, answer questions from attendees, and invite your input on a new division name. We hope to see you there!

Stay in the Loop

If, like me, you renew your membership in the fall, please be aware that renewing can change your communication preferences, and you may not be getting all of the ALSC emails. To check, log in to your ALA account, go to “Preferences,” and select “Subscribe to ALA emails.”

Children’s Literature Lecture

Today, November 10th, we celebrate our second-to-last Children’s Literature Lecture. In this lecture, an author, critic, librarian, historian, or teacher of children’s literature, from any country, presents a paper that makes a significant contribution to the field. The paper is delivered as a lecture and published by ALSC.

This year, Cynthia Leitich Smith will deliver, “Indigenous Voices: On the Page & Behind the Bylines,” hosted by the Kerlan Collection at the University of Minnesota Libraries at the Elmer L. Andersen Library. I am grateful to the selection committee: Casey O’Leary, Robyn Carr, Lucia Acosta, and Eti Berland, and look forward to Cynthia’s lecture and paper. A livestream and recording of the event will be available from the Kerlan.

Gratitude and Appointment Updates

National Institute was an amazing opportunity for me to meet so many members who are passionate about children’s and teen services and literature, whether at the Morris Seminar, one of the many panels on books and book evaluation, or elsewhere throughout the Institute. It was also exciting to share again that ALSC Institute will move from a biennial to an annual event, beginning in January 2028, and will conclude each year with the Youth Media Awards.

ALSC staff and leadership also had the chance to thank the member leaders who have steadily continued committee work. We also addressed concerns about what reunification means for teen awards, and I want to be clear: there is a strong focus on award retention!

That work is why appointments matter so much right now. Because as we approach 2027, many of us are wondering which of the fantastic 2026 titles will be honored at the Youth Media Awards in January. But the next question that may be on members’ minds is who will serve on award juries in the coming year?

If you submitted a volunteer form through ALSC or YALSA and haven’t heard from me or ALSC yet, please don’t fret! I’m working through appointments with my Presidential Advisory Group, Anne Michaud (deputy director), Ana Cackley (Program Officer for Awards), and Maggie Reagan (Program Manager for Awards and Projects). Together we are considering appointments for our many children’s and teen awards and selection lists. With more than 150 positions to fill, the process is taking a bit longer than usual.

When making appointments, ALSC officers use a holistic, intentional process to build well-rounded committees. To best serve children and teens, we want committees that reflect the full breadth of our profession and the diverse communities we serve. Rather than reviewing applications in isolation, we balance a mix of perspectives, including geographic diversity, institutional mix, lived experience and identity, and ALSC service history.

We strive to place as many passionate volunteers as possible, but demand often exceeds available seats. This is especially true for our highly competitive Award Committees, which regularly receive dozens more applicants than open seats. Because these roles carry a unique workload and high profile, appointees typically have a proven record of active committee service within ALA and ALSC first.

Please give any ALSC appointment careful thought. Ask yourself whether it’s work you want to do and whether it fits your plans and goals right now. Award committees in particular require a significant commitment. Members spend many hours reading and evaluating titles, and they are expected to follow the committee’s criteria and manual as well as ALSC policies and procedures. Many committees also have several mandatory meetings, both virtual and in person. If now isn’t the right time, that’s okay. Opportunities to serve will come again, and we hope you’ll apply in the future.

Still interested in serving? The YALSA volunteer form is now defunct, and the ALSC form can’t fully capture the new range of service interests, so please email your interest to alsccommittees@ala.org.

Ariana Sani Hussain
2026-2027 President, Association for Library Service to Children (ALSC)

The post ALSC Updates galore! appeared first on ALSC Blog.

 

Scrap Metal and Student Mobilization During World War II

0

Read More

For many of us, tossing an aluminum can into the recycling bin is an everyday act that connects us with a larger cause. During World War II, collecting scrap metal to recycle for war supplies became everyone’s civic duty. Primary sources show how the nationwide effort was mobilized with young people’s help.

In September 1942, the War Production Board—a government agency created to supervise wartime manufacturing and economic mobilization—announced a scrap metal drive for October, counting on children across the nation to join in. Students learned why the war effort needed scrap metal and what to do. Over the next few weeks, the youngsters set to work, joining many other Americans in playing a part in the war effort. Students today can explore these drives themselves through two primary sources: a newspaper item and a photograph.

Introduce “Boys and Girls!” Focus students’ attention on the image, as well as the headlines above and below it. Ask if they can read the date. What questions does this information raise?

Newspaper page with title, a boy and a girl, and paragraph text
Boys and Girls!, The Waterbury Democrat (Waterbury, CT), September 28, 1942, Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers.

Examine the page as a group:

  • What information does the newspaper item share about the campaign?
  • What role did the newspaper and the newspaper industry play in it?
  • What reasons does the newspaper item give for the campaign?

Now examine the photograph, “Manpower, junior size” by the Office of War Information in October 1942.

Sitting students watch a teacher write on a chalkboard
Howard Lieberman, “Manpower, junior size.” Farm Security Administration/Office of War Information, October 1942.

Support students as they analyze the photograph, asking questions from the Teacher’s Guide: Analyzing Photographs as needed. For example:

  • What do they notice first?
  • What do they think is happening in the photograph?
  • What surprises students about what they see?

Allow time for students to read the photograph’s item record, then discuss:

  • How does the item information affect their understanding of the photograph?

Ask students to consider both sources to support their answers to questions such as:

  • How does print versus visual media offer different approaches to the campaign?
  • Who were the intended audiences for the sources?
  • What kinds of strategies does the newspaper use to persuade students to join the campaign?
  • How might the effort to mobilize around a common cause have affected the students?

Encourage students to share how the two sources build or challenge their understanding of the war on the homefront. What new questions do the sources raise?

Find more primary sources about students and the scrap campaign in Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers. Search between August and November 1942, using phrases such as “scrap metal students.” Consider narrowing the search to your state. Search the Farm Security Administration/Office of War Information collection for “scrap metal” for photographs of the national student mobilization campaign. You might also direct students to the World War II Primary Source Set for more primary sources about the many ways that Americans mobilized for the war.

 

 

 

 

A robot just built a structure autonomously in space for the 1st time ever

0

Read More

A robot just played Tinkertoys in space, assembling the first satellite structure ever made without a human touching the controls.

The DARPA-funded project saw a robotic “truss builder” create a reflective antenna using Kapton film, composite fiber tubes and aluminum joints. The implications are huge for future missions, potentially opening up new possibilities to build — or fix — satellites in the final frontier.

“This is the first time that a structure has been autonomously constructed in space,” Sergio Pellegrino, an aerospace and civil engineering professor at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), said in a statement on Nov. 5.

The need for such spacecraft will likely rise substantially in the future, as companies assemble giant megaconstellations for cell-phone communications, AI compute and other purposes. Indeed, the ball is already rolling on such ambitious projects, generating enough hype for space startups around the globe to raise a record $20.8 billion in the third quarter of 2026 alone.

Anything that launches aboard a rocket is limited by the size of that vehicle’s fairing — the nose cone that protects payloads during their ride to space. In space, however, the ability to stretch out is practically infinite — after taking into account, of course, engineering and financing constraints.

Assembling structures robotically off Earth could therefore be revolutionary, advocates say. And the recent milestone was a step in that direction.

“This work could be useful not only for astronomy and astrophysics, but also for communications and other areas, such as building very large solar arrays for space solar power,” said Pellegrino, who’s team leader of the truss-building project, a Caltech demonstration mission called Autonomous In-Space Tensioned Reflector Assembly (ASTRA).

ASTRA built a 1.4-meter-wide (4.5-foot) structure in orbit. That’s an impressive achievement, but it just scratches the surface of what DARPA wants to accomplish via a program it calls Novel Orbital and Moon Manufacturing, Materials, and Mass-efficient Design, or NOM4D for short.

“NOM4D’s objective is to enable efficient, scalable construction of very large structures in space,” NOM4D Program Manager Andrew Detor said in a Nov. 5 DARPA statement.

“By ‘very large,’ I mean hundreds of meters or kilometers in scale. Nothing approaching that scale can be achieved today,” Detor added.

closeup illustration of a large space telescope antenna orbiting earth

Concept art for a space-based antenna autonomously assembled by a device that DARPA seeks to develop and operate via its NOM4D program. (Image credit: DARPA/Colie Wertz)

ASTRA was a demonstration, allowing researchers to check boxes and identify obstacles before shooting for a bigger goal. And the team did run into issues — specifically, time limitations, which prevented them from building additional sections of the antenna. Still, the researchers were able to prove out the third phase of a larger DARPA project.

Pellegrino’s team completed the two previous phases — defining the mission and testing the hardware in a lab — before shipping the ASTRA payload to the spaceflight company Momentus, Inc. for integration into its Vigoride 7 space tug. Vigoride 7 launched on March 30, along with many other payloads, aboard SpaceX’s Transporter-16 rideshare mission.

ASTRA flew with two prebuilt sections of a truss, a robotic “manipulator” and parts to make the rest of the truss in space. In brief communication windows totaling 15 minutes a day, engineers sent up commands and checked in on the robot’s progress as it picked up things, readied them in the right spot, and performed construction on an assembly plate.

The team overcame many “little surprises” on the way but were not able to finish the entire truss in time. Still, Pellegrino framed the effort as a success.

“Developing a payload of this complexity on such a short timeline was an enormous undertaking for our small team,” he said.

Looking into the future, he is hopeful that robots will be able to build larger telescope mirrors for observatories to peer deeper into space, as well as more advanced structures for radio telescopes to listen for distant signals.

NOM4D is also supporting a project from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, but that one will take place at the International Space Station, focusing on how to harden carbon tubes in orbit.

 

Curiosity Mars rover sizes up new ‘Nazca’ dig site | Space photo of the day for Nov. 10, 2026

0

Read More

NASA’s Mars rover Curiosity acquired this close-up image using its Mars Hand Lens Imager, showing the abundance of disc-shaped potential crystal forms on our next drill target, dubbed “Nazca.” (Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS)

NASA’s Curiosity Mars rover is sizing up its next dig site on the Red Planet.

The Curiosity team will characterize the surface composition of the Mars site, informally named “Nazca,” as thoroughly as possible before drilling into it.

What is it?

Curiosity snapped the close-up image on Oct. 18, 2026, using its Mars Hand Lens Imager (MAHLI). The image shows multiple roughly disk-shaped potential crystal formations at the rover’s next drill target.

MAHLI is located on the turret at the end of the rover’s robotic arm. It uses an onboard focusing process to make a composite of images of the same target acquired at different positions to focus on multiple features in a single image.

Why is it incredible?

Scientists theorize that the “discs and needles” texture takes its characteristic shape as crystals, or “crystal forms,” grow.

The relatively large sizes of the crystal forms at “Nazca” may provide clues about the temperatures at which they grew, as well as information about the abundance of salts and fluids in the area at the time. Complicating this picture, however, is the fact that mineral crystals can be replaced by other minerals after their original crystallization. The new minerals are known as “pseudomorphs,” because they have the same shape as the original minerals but not the same composition or molecular structure.

The Curiosity team will characterize the surface composition of Nazca — which shares its name with an ancient South American civilization that’s famous for the large designs it etched into the rock and dirt — before drilling begins. The NASA researchers will then be able to compare the deeper composition to the surface-level composition.

 

LIFE Summer Research Grant Reflections: Urban Lines, Storytelling & the History of Panama City

0

Read More

This is the final blog post in a series written by the 2026 recipients of the Duke University Libraries Summer Research Fellowship for LIFE Students. You can read the first, second, and third blog posts. Linda Garziera is a junior majoring in Economics.

“Why do you go away? So that you can come back. So that you can see the place you came from with new eyes and extra colors. And the people there see you differently, too. Coming back to where you started is not the same as never leaving.”

— Terry Pratchett, A Hat Full of Sky

The summer after my freshman year, I had the chance to participate in the inaugural program of DukeEngage in Panama. For two months, my cohort worked with the local grassroots organization Asociación Deportiva Curundú (ADC) on fighting inequality through sport, education and nutrition. As a fundraising consultant, I was focused on securing partnerships and donations from local organizations. At the same time, our program director and Duke University professor, Dr. Javier Wallace, arranged a number of trips and experiences to expose us to the history and culture of the country.

Early in the program, we drove to two cemeteries. Even twenty-five years after the United States gave up its control over Panama, that history remains alive. The “white” cemetery, protected by a painted gate, rose up on a hill dotted with gray headstones and flowers. Just next to it, a dirt road led to the cemetery for Black and Indigenous natives. From the bus, I could only see a few derelict slabs of stone marking the earth. A mango tree was shedding its fruit on the tombs. Beyond, undocumented, lay thousands of men who lost their lives to the canal.

That type of contrast lived everywhere in Panama City.

With a skyline to rival Dubai or New York, Panama City also has visible homelessness, poverty and social inequality. Luxury hotels and casinos look over neighborhoods without organized trash collection, stable plumbing and safe living standards. We worked with the community of Curundú, originally an informally grown residential area, subject to real funding barriers as well as stigma from outside its borders. Uber drivers would warn us about visiting as we headed there for our weekly dinners with the founders of ADC. During our eight weeks in the program, we heard such a variety of stories that we became convinced the only real way to understand the city was to live it ourselves.

We were staying in a former U.S. military base, “Fort Clayton,” that had been transformed into an educational center for non-profits, schools and art boutiques. So while it was outside the “real city,” it had history. And unlike most outsiders, we were able to compare the “shiny” parts of Panama City with the lived experience of many locals, including children in the ADC program.

Still, even after the summer, I had questions. If anything, getting to know the locals and getting to explore more of the history raised more questions.

My classes in Economics had taught me to look for data to model the real world. How was government funding distributed across the city? Did the historical borders for the Old Canal Zone align with modern-day neighborhoods? What was the role of newspapers in changing the public opinion of certain areas? How did the city develop after centuries of international control? Who were the forces behind urban progress, uneven development and gentrification in the “rich” areas of the city?

I needed a deeper understanding to answer these questions. I needed to take a look from the outside in.

Thanks to the Duke University Libraries Summer Research Fellowship, I was able to spend the latter part of my summer researching these topics. I was able to learn about archival research methods, sentiment analysis and overlaying GIS maps. I dove into urban studies and urban planning theories. Most importantly, I was able to deepen my connection to Panama City in such a way where when I return, I will do so with new eyes and extra colors.

—————————

When it comes to reflecting on my summer research work, I would describe it as thorough, enlightening and slightly messy. Because I wanted to tackle a number of topics and understand the connection between my questions, I had to explore a variety of data. I looked at historical borders through archives, map records, newspaper clippings over time, government funding, GIS maps, and housing rents. While I was aiming to leverage my background in economic data analysis to find some causal claims, I realized that to attack all these topics, I needed to approach my findings descriptively. Ultimately, this paid off. Instead of confining me to one data set, I was able to find patterns across observations.

For instance, using GIS maps from the Smithsonian library, I was able to verify that Curundú only has three education centers and two healthcare centers. Just outside it, in the Bella Vista corregimiento, lie 90 healthcare centers. This was supported by government funding data for social work.

In another visual analysis, I noticed how areas outside of the Old Colonial Zone had fewer major roads. The United States gained control of the canal project in 1904, and began restructuring the existing settlements alongside Gatun Lake, Changres River and Lake Alajuela as part of a zoning project. Denominated the “American Canal Zone,” the United States invested in the formation of housing, cafeterias, hotels, water systems, sanitation, pest control and other infrastructure to serve the canal workers.

Who lived in each area of the zone was determined by a policy-imposed social status, with workers segregated into “Gold Roll” and “Silver Roll” groups, based on their salary (gold or Panamanian silver coins) and race. Besides pay, this status determined the type of housing, schools, food, laundry services, vacation, and medical care available to the workers. My analysis of the GIS road network aligned with the historical data: Areas outside of the Canal Zone had been devoid of major funding, leading to uneven development and splintering urbanism.

To learn about gentrification and modern urban development, I was able to rely on Internet Archive records to observe house listings going back to 2012. In a few cases, I was able to compare historical prices to modern ones, and even undertake a visual analysis using archival photographs (from the Panama Canal Museum Collection), rental listing photos and recent Google Maps photographs.

Perhaps most interesting to the storytelling lens, I was able to track how media can shape the public perception about a place. Newspapers have adopted conflicting language to describe communities like Curundú. Sometimes the community was described as “in progress,” “in rehabilitation,” “transformed,” and other times as “poor,” “dangerous,” and “unkept.” After the government spent $108.8 million to improve housing conditions in the neighborhood, newspapers began adopting language that was positive. One particular headline stood out to me.

“Curundú, un barrio entre la pobreza y el progreso”
 “Curundú, a neighborhood between poverty and progress”
— La Prensa, Panamá

In part, my DukeEngage program attempted to teach us the importance of stories on the perception of communities. A goal of the summer was to help the organization rewrite these narratives from the inside out. We wanted to prove, through sport, that people living in Curundú were as passionate, hard-working and welcoming as anyone from any other part of the city. Therefore, the analysis of the media was particularly interesting to me.

Adopting this research process wasn’t easy. I was used to structured methods that didn’t rely as much on creativity and making-do. Often, the records and data platforms were exclusively in Spanish. I was able to unblock certain paywalls thanks to Duke Libraries. Certain data sets, however, were disorganized and lacked updates. Annoying at first, the messiness easily became one of the most interesting outcomes of this experience. Without the academic pressure of class, I was able to engage with a variety of data from both primary and secondary sources, and compare that to my experience in Panama.

Last year, I wrote a few articles highlighting the work of the grassroots organization; they were published in Panamanian newspapers. I am hoping to combine this research into a new article, with the hopes of bridging my experience in DukeEngage with my newfound understanding of Panama City. If anything, I hope to bring a deeper level of understanding to next year’s Duke in Panama cohort, which I’m confident will continue the good work of the ADCxDuke connection.

Thank you to Duke University Libraries and the LIFE Grant Committee for this incredible opportunity to advance my research.

The post LIFE Summer Research Grant Reflections: Urban Lines, Storytelling & the History of Panama City appeared first on Duke University Libraries Blogs.

 

See the first images from the new ZWO Seestar S30 Plus — a smart telescope aimed at beginners

0

Read More

As rival makers announce increasingly ambitious smart telescopes, ZWO has taken a different approach. Its new Seestar S30 Plus launches today and will be available online from Seestar’s website and Amazon, just in time for Christmas. Better still, we’ve been using it for a month and can bring you a first look.

Announced a few months after the flagship Seestar S50 Pro and replacing the now-discontinued Seestar S30, the new Seestar S30 Plus retains its 30mm aperture and compact chassis, but upgrades to four-element apochromatic optics with extra-low dispersion (ED) glass and two 3.7-megapixel cameras.

The Seestar S30 Plus smart telescope sitting on a wooden beam in garden, with foliage in the background.

The ZWO Seestar S30 Plus is a new sub-$500 smart telescope with upgraded optics and dual 3.7MP cameras. (Image credit: Jamie Carter)

Both produce 1,440 x 2,560-pixel images, while a much-improved 43.5-degree wide-angle camera can capture the Milky Way, constellations, star trails and nightscapes. Built-in filters, a mosaic mode and equatorial (EQ) tracking add considerable deep-sky astrophotography potential.

For a telescope weighing just 3.64 lbs (1.65 kg), it’s impressive. It easily fits into a camera bag and could happily live on a bookshelf.

The Seestar S30 Plus lying on a wooden beam in the closed position.

The Seestar S30 Plus weighs just 3.64 lbs (1.65 kg) and fits in a camera bag easily. (Image credit: Jamie Carter)

I’ve already photographed the Andromeda Galaxy (M31), the Pleiades (M45), the Dumbbell Nebula (M27) and the North America Nebula (NGC 7000). The results are excellent for such a small instrument, especially when imaging nebulas with its built-in dual-band filter, which helps reduce light pollution.

The Seestar app adds new in-app post-processing options, so you don’t have to mess around with any of that — though you can also export everything as lossless FITS files. The S30 Plus also includes a magnetic solar filter, enabling you to indulge in solar photography safely.

Three space images captured using the Seestar S30 Plus: the North American Nebula, the Pleiades and star trails.

The North America Nebula (NGC 7000), the Pleiades (M45) and a star trail imaged using the Seestar S30 Plus. (Image credit: Jamie Carter)

With Dwarflab’s $1,299 Draco (3.5-inch/90mm aperture) recently landed in stores and Vaonis’ own $4,990 Atlas (3.1-inch/80mm aperture) not available until 2027, ZWO’s decision to offer an upgraded entry-level smart telescope that buyers can get their hands on right now looks particularly smart.

The Andromeda Galaxy (M31) photographed using the Seestar S30 Plus.

The Andromeda Galaxy (M31) photographed using the Seestar S30 Plus. (Image credit: Jamie Carter)

With ZWO’s pattern of delivering cheaper smart telescopes without sacrificing on quality, the Seestar S30 Plus could be one of Christmas 2026’s best gifts for anyone interested in astronomy — and maybe that’s the point of it. Either way, first impressions are good. A full review is coming tomorrow, so check back at Space.com to find out our full thoughts and testing.

 

Lit Hub Daily: November 10, 2026

0

Read Morewilliam faulkner

TODAY: In 1950, William Faulkner is awarded the Nobel Prize in literature.

 

Secrets, Chips and Spycraft: The Nvidia C.E.O. Scandal

0

Read More 

Over the weekend, Jensen Huang, the chief executive and co-founder of Nvidia — which makes the chips that power artificial intelligence — admitted to having an affair with a woman who has been determined by U.S. officials to be a spy. That revelation came after The New York Times broke the story of how U.S. intelligence officers uncovered what they say was a plot by Alice Huang to use their relationship to funnel information to Beijing.

Tripp Mickle, a White House correspondent for The Times, explains how Beijing tried to compromise one of the tech executives closest to President Trump, and what the scandal could mean for a company with enormous influence over the future of A.I. — and the entire American economy.

Guest: Tripp Mickle, a tech reporter for The New York Times.

Background reading: 

Photo: Manuel Orbegozo/Reuters

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. 

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

 

I got what I wanted. Why am I unhappy?

0

Read MoreSometimes achieving a goal is elating and feels like an accomplishment. Other times, it invites anxiety, deflation or even grief. Psychiatrist Pooja Lakshmin, author of the upcoming book Quantum Shifts: A Practical Framework for Navigating Life’s Biggest Changes, urges people to pay close attention to these feelings of grief. They might give you clarity on what you truly value in life.

Follow us on Instagram: @nprlifekit
Sign up for our newsletter here.
Have an episode idea or feedback you want to share? Email us at lifekit@npr.org
Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include sponsor-free listening and convenient playlists of popular help topics like personal finance, getting healthy, and more. Learn more at plus.npr.org.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy 

How the Telephone Changed the World

0

Read Moreretro old fashioned vintage telephone

A beige plastic telephone sits on a wooden table. The handset, attached by a coiled cord, rests in its cradle. The base has a clear dial with ten finger holes. The telephone is the most ordinary of household objects but, sitting silently on the table, it seems to portend something. It’s bound to ring.

Suddenly it does: a metallic brrrrring, distinctive and familiar. Nearby on the carpet, a smiling girl with pigtails and a ruffled-sleeve dress leaps to her feet, races over, and picks up the handset. She holds a stuffed toy duck to the receiver. Quack! Quack! Quack!

“That’s no way to answer the phone, Susie!” says an older boy, appearing in the frame. He has neatly brushed brown hair and wears a white shirt buttoned to the neck. He grabs the handset from Susie and demonstrates proper etiquette: “Hello. Matthews residence. This is Jimmy.” He listens and speaks again. “Just a minute, please.”

A grown-up arrives, smiling, also wearing his hair neatly parted, with a button-down shirt and khaki trousers. “Uncle Bill,” Jimmy tells him earnestly, “Captain Adams wants to talk to you.”

“Thanks, Jimmy,” says Bill. He takes the handset and holds it to his ear, stretching its coiled cord. “Hi, Captain, this is Bill,” he says. “No, we don’t usually have ducks answer the phone. That one belongs to Susie.” No time for jokes, though. Captain Adams needs Uncle Bill to come at once. These are the whitest white people you’ve ever seen, performing a fantasy of middle-class American life familiar from TV sitcoms that featured Wally and Beaver, Mike and Robbie and Chip.

Eighty-nine years into the telephone era, this wholesome scene opened a movie called We Learn About the Telephone, made in Technicolor on behalf of American Telephone and Telegraph (AT&T) by a well-known Hollywood producer, Jerry Fairbanks. The film was distributed as a public service to schools around the country and played for a captive audience of children in classrooms. In 1965, the United States had one telephone for every four people; the number had tripled in the two decades since World War II. It already seemed the universal appliance. Yet the phone company—there was basically just one—still thought its customers needed instruction.

Back to the show. Little Jimmy asks: “What did people do before the telephone was invented? How’d they get messages to each other in a hurry?”

The paradox of the telephone was its plainness, its tendency to hide in the background while changing everything around it.

Thus prompted, Uncle Bill draws a cartoon character called Mister Man, who begins to speak. (If his voice sounds familiar, it’s because AT&T hired the best: Mel Blanc, the onetime vaudevillian who voiced Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, and many other characters.) Mister Man guides us through a potted history of human communication, beginning with the “cave men” and the Egyptians. “The only way Mr. Caveman knew how to get a message from one place to another was to send a runner,” Bill explains. Greeks used runners, too, and Romans, until they discovered horses. Then came knights and cowboys. “That’s a Pony Express rider!” says Jimmy. “That’s right,” Bill replies. “But man wanted to send messages faster than a runner or a horse could travel.” A cartoon Indian sends smoke signals. Sailors communicate from ship to ship with flashing mirrors and blinking lights. Then the telegraph appears. “Man has always been able to solve his problems by inventing new things…The telegraph was, and still is, wonderful,” Uncle Bill explains. But the telegraph was not enough. “Mister Man wanted to send his voice over a distance, to carry on a real conversation,” Uncle Bill continues. “Then in 1876 a man named Alexander Graham Bell found a way. He invented the telephone.”

This was the story in a nutshell. It was not entirely true, but it served as the essential origin story of its sponsor, the greatest commercial enterprise the world had ever known. AT&T, known as the Bell System, held more capital and generated more income than most nation-states. Its scientific research arm, the Bell Telephone Laboratories, was unique in the world, eventually the source of eleven Nobel Prizes in physics and chemistry. Mister Man was right to place the telephone at the head of a line of increasingly powerful information technologies. Humanity had learned to send its voice—its many voices—disembodied, far and wide, eliminating walls, bridging towns and countryside, inviting conversation with strangers unseen.

No single genius accomplished that, and it didn’t happen all at once. No one had felt the absence of telephones before they existed, and at first hardly anyone understood what they might be good for. Much that seems obvious in retrospect had to be learned by people feeling their way toward the future.

*

AT&T had no trouble inserting its potted history into the curriculum of millions of primary-school children, and after the history lesson came some instruction in how to use the device. It was hardly necessary. Most people had a telephone at home that looked exactly like the one in the movie. The Western Electric model 500 was ubiquitous across the United States. It first appeared in 1949 and hardly changed as the years passed: a thermoplastic shell screwed to a metal base, a clear plastic finger wheel, and a handset with a mouthpiece and an ear-piece attached by a cord twisted in a stiff spiral. The phone was heavy, about four pounds, but a person could pick it up with two fingers under the cradle while nestling the handset between shoulder and neck. That was actually comfortable, when people got used to it. If they opened the base by turning it over and removing some screws, they could see a pair of brass bells, with a small clapper between them, and a few colored wires. Ordinary as it was, it spoke of modernity, with its sculpted plastic. No other household gadget had anything like that dial.

When the telephone rang, it did not chirp or chime or play a tune; it just rang. The sound was the same throughout the United States and much of the world: an electromechanical bell ringing for two seconds at a time, with a four-second pause in between. (Older people will never forget that sound, and it can still be heard in old movies and television shows. Nostalgists have been known to install “Old Telephone” as the ringtone for their smartphone.)

At first the telephones were all black; then AT&T customers could choose among ivory, gray, beige, and a few more colors. The phones remained simple, undramatic, and unadorned. Yet they ripped invisible tunnels through space—like wormholes, only real.

More than eight in ten homes in the United States had a Bell System telephone—owned by the company, merely on loan to the customer. No other company was allowed to manufacture telephones, and everyone’s telephones were the same. People thought that was a normal state of affairs: it had always been like that and it always would be.

The phone was a simple object with not so much as an on-off switch, but the Bell System never stopped educating the public in its proper use. Uncle Bill and Mister Man offered children some dos and don’ts. Don’t shout into the telephone. Do use your normal speaking voice. Speak directly into the mouthpiece. It’s important to speak clearly. Don’t let the phone ring too long before answering—“but if you’re the person making the call, you should let the phone ring eight to ten times.”

There is even a lesson in dialing, using the finger wheel to choose the desired telephone number: “When you dial, you should make sure you bring your finger all the way around to the finger stop. Then for each number let the dial go all the way back by itself. Each number. All the way. Then let go. See?”

Everyone knew how to dial the phone. It was no harder than, for example, learning to tie one’s shoelaces. But the Bell System left little to chance. It was relentless. Far more than outsiders knew, it had made itself the author of its own story. The company subsidized books by supposedly independent authors; it sponsored articles, speeches, and pamphlets; and it arranged lectures for business schools and law schools on such matters as public-utility regulation. The slick Jerry Fairbanks movie was one of many instructional films and cartoons. Schoolteachers received a twenty-four-page booklet, also titled We Learn About the Telephone, full of helpful material. A section called “The Telephone Brings Everybody Together” listed, with illustrations, some of the people you can call: the repairman, storekeepers, the fireman, the policeman, and the doctor.

Half a century earlier, the Bell System advertised itself as “The Sign Board of Civilization.” Its full name was the American Telephone and Telegraph Company and Associated Companies. Its logo was a great bell, deliberately resembling the Liberty Bell, bearing the words “Local and Long Distance Telephone.” Advertisements in magazines and newspapers said:

Wherever you see this sign, it stands for civilization. It is the sign of one of the most powerful influences for broadening human intelligence…

Bell telephone service has brought the entire country up to the same instant of progress.

It has unified the Nation…

You can see this march of progress right in your own neighborhood. Every little while some neighbor has a Bell telephone put in. If you have one, every new subscriber enlarges the scope of your personal contact.

The copywriters could not resist adding a threat: “If you have not, every new telephone makes you the more isolated.” This was the essence of the company’s business model: every new subscriber adds value for every other.

*

Children in 1965 were growing up in a world transformed, normal though it seemed to them. Everyone had from birth at least a vague awareness of an invisible web of voices, bringing the unreachable within reach. It was already hard to remember the earlier world, where the loudest shout would barely carry to the next room. The paradox of the telephone was its plainness, its tendency to hide in the background while changing everything around it. When the telephone was still new, Marcel Proust in France saw it already growing old and familiar, “a supernatural instrument before whose miracles we used to stand amazed, and which we now employ without giving it a thought, to summon our tailor or order an ice cream.”

By 1965, teaching children how to dial the telephone was unnecessary. But in the next century the knowledge would be lost again, and YouTube would feature videos of youngsters baffled by ancient rotary telephones. “This is like phones that my mom used as a kid?” “How does this even work?” “It looks like a phone, it has a telephone and it has numbers.”

The telephone had other inventors besides Alexander Graham Bell, an amateur who did not know much about electricity. Neither the idea nor the device came to any one person in a visionary flash. Even with the new invention in hand, the most expert entrepreneurs and government officials had trouble seeing what it was for. The president of the Western Union Telegraph Company dismissed it. “What use could this company make of an electrical toy?” he said, thus condemning his business to stagnation and decline. We might say the telephone was invented by the people who used it. They made it what it is, creating new habits and a new language as they went. Or we might say the telephone invented itself: it was an inevitability; it had to come, and when it came it could not be stopped, an invasive species dragging its wires through cracks in the familiar world.

We have learned by now that gadgets can have a life of their own and an influence we cannot evade. Using a technology changes a person. Using a technology changes a culture.

First the telephone was a curiosity, then a luxury item, and then an ordinary necessity. In 1965, people made something like 100 billion telephone calls a year, long and short, local and long-distance; that number has increased a thousand-fold, but even then the telephone had helped humanity coalesce into a wired collective—trading news and rumors, mingling public intelligence with private gossip. The telephone company could help its customers learn about the telephone, but it could hardly explain the changes that four-pound box of plastic and metal had already worked in the fabric of modern life and in the psyches of the people who put their ears and mouths to it.

The telephone enabled the expansion of cities and the creation of suburbs by freeing workspaces and living spaces from the requirement of proximity. It encouraged nationhood by softening the differences between regions. “The service of the telephone in the consolidation of our Union was an epoch-making service,” wrote Michael Pupin at Columbia University in 1930. “No other country availed itself of the consolidating power of the telephone as much as this country did. No other country needed it so much.”

The telephone brought a generation of women into the workforce for the first time. The job of telephone operator—a profession like none that had ever existed—required intelligence, physical dexterity, mental focus, and genial patience, and it was decided by universal consent that the job belonged to women.

The telephone marked the beginning of a rebalancing of the senses in human culture: it re-centered sound and hearing, which had been deprecated during the long rise of text as the mode of communication most reliable, most stable, most respected. “As there was an Enlightenment, so too was there an ‘Ensoniment,’” argues Jonathan Sterne, a scholar of media and culture. That rebalancing continues.

Was it a connector, a unifier? Or a disrupter of precious solitude? Sociologists argued about what the telephone had done to shape the evolution of modern culture, to alter social habits and relationships. They even argued about whether it could have done anything—whether any technology in itself could dictate human affairs. Some doubted that. People made the telephone, some said; people decided how to use it, so let’s not fall into the trap of granting it agency. The violin doesn’t play the violinist. “No single invention—and no group of them taken together in isolation from nontechnological elements—ever changed the direction in which a society was going,” George Daniels wrote in 1970. “Habits seem to grow out of other habits far more directly than they do out of gadgets.”

But we have learned by now that gadgets can have a life of their own and an influence we cannot evade. Using a technology changes a person. Using a technology changes a culture.

After the telegraph laid the groundwork, establishing the possibility of nearly instantaneous long-distance communication across networks of wires, the telephone became the first piece of what later coalesced into the phenomenon called mass media—the incessant, ubiquitous exchange of information conducted point-to-point via telephones and telefaxes, broadcast via radio and television, and stored and shared as phonographs, photographs, and cinema. Media, distinct from mechanism, required theorists, such as Marshall McLuhan, who asserted its primacy with his clever slogan “The medium is the message.”

The telephone became a cultural artifact and a generator of other artifacts. The ability to speak across space transformed business organizations, military tactics, the rules of etiquette, the rituals of romance. Each profession evolved in its own way, from news gathering to sex work. (“The prostitute was a specialist, and the call-girl is not,” McLuhan declared coolly in 1965.) Other powerful technologies arose alongside the telephone and followed after, but the telephone was special. It conferred upon every individual a power to communicate that was essential in the development of modern life.

It left a trail of appurtenances: the party line, the busy signal, the dial tone, the collect call, the wiretap, the answering machine, the telephone book, the telephone booth. Telephone booths, boxes, kiosks, and cabins, varying from country to country, appeared on public sidewalks; these structures had no other purpose but to house telephones and shelter their users. Anyone old enough to remember telephone booths retains a mental image of a characteristic design—in Britain, a cast-iron box, usually painted red, with a rounded roof, a single door, two mullioned windows, and a classical pediment bearing the royal crest. Some urban children imagined that pay phones whisked their coins through underground pipes to a central repository. Besides allowing people to make calls in semi-privacy, telephone booths spun off oddities of their own. In the mid-twentieth century, pranksters competed to see how many people could squeeze into a telephone booth at once. The comic-book hero Superman used telephone booths to shed his civilian garb; this became so familiar a trope that it inspired a sight gag in the 1978 movie Superman in which Clark Kent dashed for a phone booth and was dismayed to find its modern replacement, a pay phone mounted on a post. Special heroes required special phones: Dick Tracy a wrist radio, Batman his Bat Phone, and Maxwell Smart his shoe phone. Star Trek’s spacefarers had flip phones (“communicators”) twenty years before such things appeared in real life. Meanwhile, the science-fiction paladin Doctor Who traveled through space and time in a vehicle that took the form of the British telephone box. It was bigger on the inside than it appeared from the outside. All phone booths were.

And then, in an eye blink, the phone booths were left to rust, the phone books stopped arriving at the door, and the busy signal and the party line and all the rest became memories. The telephone turned into something else entirely.

______________________________

the telephone

From The Telephone: A New History by James Gleick. Copyright © 2026. Published by Farrar, Straus and Giroux, a division of Macmillan.

 

What is the Best Literary TV Adaptation of All Time? Day Two

0

Read More

After a big first day, just 32 of the boob tube’s finest fare are left in contention. A ton of you participated yesterday—thank you!—though a good chunk of you personally let me down. But more on that later.

The first round was surprising, with some pretty major upsets. Three shows that I thought would go far didn’t:

– Sex and the City is out. Moved to the suburbs, presumably.

– Bridgerton is out, and maybe forgot to vote because of such a busy day of rogering? Or whatever they called it back then?

– Hannibal lost to Killing Eve in what must have been a tough call for our readers who were on Tumblr at a very specific time and are currently bereft with AO3 being down.

Our top seed in Carnage, Game of Thrones, only got 60% of the vote, which is a much worse margin than I would have guessed for the big Dragons & Nudity show. Looks like it’s any show’s to win at this point.

Another surprise in Cerebral was Watchmen barely squeaking by Ripley. I didn’t realize the Italian neorealist Hot Priest vehicle had so many fans, but as a big slow cinema and Caravaggio guy, I respect it.

The biggest upset, both in terms of seeding and the Bracket in My Heart, is 16th seed Sherlock beating top seed The Leftovers. A beautiful show with literary themes, career best performances, and ambition to spare couldn’t make it out of the first round? In the Cerebral quadrant? Look, I don’t have much to say about this that is appropriate for a public forum, but you all owe me an apology, at very least.

But it’s okay, I’m over it. What are we looking forward today?

– In Carnage, we have Spy vs. Spy in The Night Manager vs. Slow Horses. Will a suave Tom Hiddleston beat the disgusting Gary Oldman? Either way, we win.

– In Cerebral, Wolf Hall is up against Mindhunter in a sort of battle of manipulators. Certainly there’s a lot of blood on a lot of hands in both of these shows.

– And in Carnal, it’s a classic horny off with Outlander versus Normal People. Which small screen sex scenes will steam it’s to the top?

But there are lots of great TV adaptations still in the mix, so scroll on down and vote! If you need me, I’ll be taking a long walk and sending some sad updates to my “Guilty Remnant Smokers” group chat.

–James Folta

[Click image to enlarge and zoom]

*

INSTRUCTIONS:

It’s simple: for every match-up, pick your favorite. We’re looking for the best show, not necessarily the most faithful adaptation—though that may factor into your thinking. Or not! In short, go with your gut. We’ll tabulate up the results using our best liberal arts major math, and bring you the results tomorrow.

*

VOTING SCHEDULE:

Round of 64: Voting open now until tonight at 7:00 PM EST (Results are here)

➤ Round of 32: Voting open now until 7:00 PM EST

Round of 16: Voting open Wednesday, November 11th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST

Round of 8: Voting open Thursday, November 12th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST

The Quarter Finals: Voting open Friday, November 13th from 10:00 AM, until Sunday November 15th at 7:00 PM EST

The Finals: Voting open Monday, November 16th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST

And the winner will be announced on Tuesday, November 17th!

*

HOW TO VOTE:

There are little voting forms at the bottom of each match-up. Simply click and move along, like changing the channel on your TV.

*

*

MATCHUP:

Game of Thrones (1) vs. Sharp Objects (9)

******************************************

game of thrones adaptationGame of Thrones (2011)

Emotional manipulation, with dragons

Based on: George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series (1996–…)
Subgenres: Everyone Dies • The Last Stand of Monoculture • Water Cooler Fodder

 

David Benioff and D. B. Weiss changed the game with their adaptation of George R.R. (for Really Really Slow At Finishing the Next Book) Martin’s already popular books, bringing the swords, dragons, morally complex characters, and unrepentant violence to life with big budget visuals and great performances. The books’ soap-opera-dense political intrigue and “kill ‘em all” approach to character development felt remarkably fresh in 2011—you never knew who was going to die, or have sex!—and it’s hard to overstate the show’s popularity: For years of Sundays, everyone you knew was going to a Game of Thrones watch party. Some of the shine came off when the show’s plot outran the books—and the writers couldn’t stick the landing—but when there are real children in the real world named Daenerys, it’s hard to deny the GoT legacy. –JF

Put it on when you want to feel better about your office’s politics.

See also:

How I Built My Own Game of Thrones Iron Throne • The 50 Best Fictional Dragons, Ranked • In Praise of Remixing Shakespeare

••••••••••vs•••••••••• 

sharp objectsSharp Objects (2018)

A crime series about how fucked up it is that neither Amy Adams nor Patricia Clarkson have won any Oscars

Based on: Gillian Flynn’s Sharp Objects (2006)
Subgenres: Southern Gothic • Rollerskating Gothic • Amy Adams Whispering Gothic • Mommy Issues Gothic

 

I watched all of Sharp Objects in one day because I’m insane, and now my brain is different. This series is the definition of vibes and atmosphere, the definition of creeping dread and sickening suspense. On the surface this is a story about a struggling crime reporter (Adams) being dispatched to her hometown to report on a murder, and ultimately being sucked back into dark family drama and her mother’s (Clarkson) unstable orbit. But actually, this is a show about beautiful wallpaper and dark corners and oppressive Southern heat. It’s a mother-daughter story told through a cracked mirror. The show itself is a very sharp object. –MC

Put it on when you are looking to get jump-scared by Sydney Sweeney.

See also:

On the Feminine Urge to Murder • Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Quandaries: Women Finding Their Power in Literature

*

MATCHUP:

The Handmaid’s Tale (12) vs. Roots (4)

******************************************

the handmaids taleThe Handmaid’s Tale (2017)

Systemic oppression with fun little hats

Based on: Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale (1985)
Subgenres: Color Coding • It Could Happen Here • The Discourse

 

The first season of The Handmaid’s Tale premiered less than four months into Donald Trump’s first presidency, which made the show—which imagines a totalitarian American in which women are utterly subjugated—even more haunting. It is an effective, moving translation of Atwood’s beloved novel, not least on account of its excellent cast, including Elisabeth Moss, Samira Wiley, Alexis Bledel, Ann Dowd, and Joseph Fiennes.

Unfortunately, in later seasons, after it outruns the book, the show gets stuck in the mud and kind of devolves into torture porn. But hey, we’ll always have the iconography. –ET

Put it on when you have just voted against fascists.

See also:

The Handmaid’s Tale Adapts More Than the Novel: Here is America • Margaret Atwood on How She Came to Write The Handmaid’s Tale • Watching The Handmaid’s Tale While Transitioning • What Makes Somebody a Mother? On the New Season of The Handmaid’s Tale

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Roots (1977)

A very American family saga

Based on: Alex Haley’s Roots (1976)
Subgenres: Classroom Classics • It Did Happen Here • Generational Stories

 

One of the most watched miniseries in American TV history and a seminal dramatic portrayal of America through slavery and the Civil War. The show almost got pulled when ABC executives saw how unflinching Roots was about the brutality of slavers, especially when they were being portrayed by some of TV’s most recognizable white faces. The network insisted on adding a concerned white captain who isn’t in the book. Haley’s novel was known for being the first popular work of fiction to present the horrors of the Middle Passage, which the show maintains. Some of the novel’s nuance is lost in the translation to TV, but Roots is excellent and anchored in great performances, including an early performance by LeVar Burton. –JF

Put it on when you want to remember when network TV executives made serious shows.

See also:

How the TV Adaptation of Alex Haley’s Roots Sparked a Cultural Awakening • Nikki Giovanni on Race, Hope, Fatherhood, and Roots

*

MATCHUP:

Say Nothing (6) vs. Justified (3)

******************************************

Say Nothing (2024)

Revolution retold

Based on: Patrick Radden Keefe’s Say Nothing (2018)
Subgenres: Based on a True Story • Fight for Your Rights • Party Politics

 

Patrick Radden Keefe’s excellent book was my first introduction to both the Troubles and its cast of determined revolutionaries. Keefe’s project, centering on the mysterious disappearance of civilian Jean McConville in 1972, explored a centuries-long occupation through the eyes of a few key players. Josh Zetumer’s adaptation also managed to render the political personal, but this viewer admired how the show’s structure left space for thematic exploration.

Drifting from the tight focus on I.R.A. icon Dolours Price gives the series air to float big questions. So on the one hand, we have Lola Petticrew eating up scenery as moxie incarnate, but on the other, we have meaty arguments on statecraft, paramilitary strategy, and political atonement.

I also felt, watching this show, how alive the conflict is. And how unsettled! Say Nothing framed every single one of its nine episodes with a winky chyron noting Gerry Adams’ denial that he was ever a member of the I.R.A. Maybe the revolution will not be televised because the past isn’t even past. –BKA

Put it on when you want to topple the system in a cool sweater.

See also:

Patrick Radden Keefe on Secrets, Lies, and the Murky Line Between Licit and Illicit

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Justified (2010)

A years-long argument for practicing one’s quick draw

Based on: Elmore Leonard’s short story “Fire in the Hole” (2001)
Subgenres: Digging Coal Together • Big Hats • Shooty Show

 

You might think it would be difficult to hang six seasons of a television show on a single short story. And it is—in the sense that the story in question, which introduces US Marshal Raylan Given, who believes in justice over rules, and who comes back home to Harlan, Kentucky, where he finds himself squaring off against an old coal mining buddy, Boyd Crowder, now on the other side of the law, has little to do with the overall plot of the show beyond the first few episodes. But famously, showrunner Graham Yost gave all the writers bracelets with “WWED” on them, for “What Would Elmore Do?” And you can tell. The writing is great, the acting is great, the tone—a sort of Southern Gothic meets Western meets modern crime drama—is electric, and the whole thing is entertaining as hell from top to tail. –ET

Put it on when you wish you could take matters into your own hands.

See also:

The Search for the Funniest Crime Novel Ever Written • 43 of the Most Iconic Short Stories in the English Language • 40 Writer’s Writers Whomst Readers Should Read

*

MATCHUP:

The Night Manager (10) vs. Slow Horses (2)

******************************************

The Night Manager (2016)

Falling for the arms dealer’s wife is never a good idea

Based on: John Le Carré’s The Night Manager (1993)
Subgenres: Hidden Identities • Doomed But Sexy Relationships Between Spies • Globe Trotting • Communicating Via Secret Channels

 

Le Carré’s taut novel is his first set outside of the Cold War, and the BBC adaptation is propulsive and tense. Le Carré’s read on the post-9/11 political situation was nearly always spot on, and The Night Manager’s collision between a stretched-thin security apparatus and rapacious war profiteers still feels relevant—strip the charm from Hugh Laurie’s evil gunrunner character and dunk him in lamer, ketamine-dusted clothes and you basically have Elon Musk and Starlink.

The show is gorgeous and has a cast of amazing British actors in nuanced roles: a coy and competent Tom Hiddleston, a pregnant and mad Olivia Colman, a sadly scheming Tom Hollander, and on and on. The second season—an overly complicated reunion trying to do a Y Tu Mama Tambien thing, I guess?—is skippable, but the first season is a lean and exciting thriller that more than makes up for it. –JF

Put it on when you feel nostalgic for your childhood dream of becoming a spy.

See also:

A Writer For Our Time: Why John le Carré’s Work Remains More Essential Than Ever • Spying is Lying: How David Cornwell Became John Le Carré

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Slow Horses (2022)

Gary Oldman zinger vehicle

Based on: Mick Herron’s Slough House novels (2010–2025)
Subgenres: Losers • Our Peerless Leader • Highbrow Fart Jokes • Elevated Espionage

 

It’s a brilliant premise: a group of MI5 agents, all of whom have made career-ruining mistakes of one kind or another, are relegated to a department entitled Slough House, where they are made to do menial labor to avoid being completely left out in the cold. Their fearless leader is the relentlessly disgusting, but equally brilliant Jackson Lamb (Gary Oldman) who insults, cajoles, and gaslights his foot-dragging staff into feats of daring heroism. It is exciting in all the normal ways that a good spy drama can be, but unlike many of its kind, it is very, very funny, balancing mordant wit, slapstick, and, let’s face it, highly amusing Britishisms. Plus, Kristin Scott Thomas always hits. –ET

Put it on when you are really good at failing.

See also:

Slow Horses, Starring Gary Oldman, is Worth the Slow Burn

*

*

MATCHUP:

Friday Night Lights (1) vs. Killing Eve (9)

******************************************

friday night lightsFriday Night Lights (2006)

Football is really that serious

Based on: H.G. Bissinger’s Friday Night Lights: A Town, a Team, and a Dream (1990)
Subgenres: Real Eyes Realize Clear Eyes • Multiple Adaptations • Pep Talks That Make You Tear Up • Hunks Crying

 

Friday Night Lights has a ton of fans who don’t know (or care) a thing about football, a testament to the show’s quality and popularity. But the football, high school, and even Texas of it all was always backdrop for Friday Night Lights, which kept its focus on its characters and their emotional and relational lives. Some of the plot lines got a little goofy and soap opera-y—the second season was shortened due to the 2007 writers strike and got garbled—but you cannot beat the performances. And the show doesn’t get enough credit for being cinematically experimental: the music and shots were genuinely surprising and even anti-realist in places. Plus the production’s embrace of improvisation, empowering the cast to make their own choices about dialogue and blocking, gave FNL an immediacy that escapes other prestige shows. –JF

Put it on when you need a halftime speech to turn a bad day around.

See also:

On the Truth and Lies of Friday Night Football

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Killing Eve (2018)

What’s a little assassination between two consenting adults?

Based on: Luke Jennings’s Codename Villanelle (2017)
Subgenres: The Thrill of the Chase • Recreational Murder • Tension

 

The heart of Killing Eve is of course the mutual obsession between assassin Villanelle and her hunter, Eve Polastri. Comer’s Villanelle is volatile and ruthless, which is to say she’s a lot of fun, and while Eve might appear more grounded on the surface, the two women are (in the most complimentary way possible) perfectly matched freaks. Phoebe Waller-Bridge served as the show’s head writer during the first season of this sharp, sexy cat and mouse game, then Emerald Fennel in season two; fans remained divided over later seasons, particularly the show’s ending, but that’s okay. We’ll always have the kitchen scene. –OS

Put it on when you need to live vicariously through fiction instead of staying at home with your cat.

See also:

Serial Killer As Instagram Influencer? On Killing Eve‘s Cool Girl Assassin • The Visible and Invisible Women of Killing Eve • Subverting the Male Gaze in Killing Eve

*

MATCHUP:

Heated Rivalry (5) vs. Interview with the Vampire (12)

******************************************

Heated Rivalry (2025)

The sexy hockey show that spawned a thousand fanfics

Based on: Rachel Reid’s Game Changers series (2018–present)
Subgenres: O O O O Canada • Erotica on Ice • SPORTS • Hot Steamy Yearning

 

No one saw the sexy hockey show coming. Originally developed for the Canadian streaming platform Crave, it got a surprise simultaneous release (um, no pun intended) on HBO Max and instantly became a hit—hopefully whoever acquired it has gotten a raise. The show, in which two rival hockey players fall in lust, and then love, over many years, benefits from the charisma and chemistry of its leads, but also from solid writing and an undercurrent of surprisingly unsaccharine hope. It’s a gay fantasia, gloriously optimistic, honestly funny, and yep, pretty damn hot. –ET

Put it on when you are alone.

See also:

How Heated Rivalry Imagines a More Inclusive NHL • Why Heated Rivalry is the Perfect Adaptation of the Romance Novel’s Strict Conventions

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Interview with the Vampire (2022)

Even Anne Rice can’t sue from beyond the grave

Based on: Anne Rice’s Interview with the Vampire (1991)
Subgenres: Toxic Yaoi • Tom Cruise Wishes • Does This Count As Romantasy?

 

All of my gayest and most insane friends are obsessed with Interview with the Vampire, which is how you know it’s awesome. The show follows the plot of the book but, since Anne Rice is now dead and can’t get litigious about it, the two central vampires (Louis and Lestat) can finally be openly gay. This is what gives this show its extra sauce: the fact that Louis and Lestat can have hate sex and play evil mind games with each other as they fall in love. It’s an adaptation that dares to ask: Did we make these characters psychotic enough the first time around? Is there anything we can do to bump up the crazy factor? Can we turn that dial to 11? –MC

Put it on when you need to look at hot men in high-waisted pants.

See also:

Leigh Bardugo on 50 Years of Interview with the Vampire and the Immortality of Anne Rice’s Lestat

*

MATCHUP:

Outlander (6) vs. Normal People (3)

******************************************

Outlander (2014)

Horny across time

Based on: Diana Gabaldon’s Outlander series (1991-2021)
Subgenres: Anachronistic Hygiene • Gorgeous Settings • Don’t Mess With Stone Circle Magic

 

This show is a perfectly elevated soap opera. Outlander has lots of depth—shifting allegiances, political machinations, and interpersonal dramas—but it’s also gorgeous and sexy, shot in amazing locations with a dashing cast. The story moves across its more than a hundred episodes—through time, relationships, significant historical events—but never loses track of what the viewer really wants. Showrunner and developer Ronald D. Moore worked on Battlestar Galactica, For All Mankind, and a bunch of the Star Treks, so he knows his high concept, high drama TV. We debated putting this one in the “cozy” category since it’s so good at satisfying your expectations, but Outlander is smarter and more complex than it might appear on the surface. –JF

Put it on when you feel like you were born in the wrong time period(s) and want to be embraced on the moors.

See also:

A Love Letter to Lovers of Outlander • This is the supernatural, time-traveling romance series YOU SHOULD be watching.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Normal People (2020)

Sex, Angst, Sligo

Based on: Sally Rooney’s Normal People (2018)
Subgenres: What Happens in Sligo • Connell’s Gold Chain • Faithful Adaptations

 

Rare is it that an adaptation is neither better nor worse than its source material, but rather, despite covering the same ground, an ideal companion piece. Lenny Abrahamson’s Normal People is deeply faithful to Rooney’s breakout novel, while also delivering a visual mood that expands on the book. Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal are both excellent, bringing a convincing vulnerability to the screen. Also the sex is pretty damn good! –ET

Put it on when you miss having strong emotions.

See also:

Watching Normal People Have Very Good Sex (on the Small Screen) • Lenny Abrahamson on Adapting Sally Rooney’s Normal People for TV • Dispatches from an extra on the set of Hulu’s Normal People. • Read Sally Rooney’s first short story about Marianne and Connell.

*

MATCHUP:

True Blood (10) vs. Orange is the New Black (2)

******************************************

True Blood (2008)

The Sins of My Yellow Country Teeth

Based on: Charlaine Harris’s “The Southern Vampire Mysteries” (2001-2013)
Subgenres: Very TV-y TV • Dirty Sexy Bloody • An HBO Show

 

If Charlaine Harris’s cozy-ish mystery series would’ve never existed without Anne Rice’s Vampire Chronicles, the recent adaptation of the Rice books wouldn’t be what it is without the campy soapy fun of True Blood lingering in our collective memories. When our story begins, vampires have recently “come out of the coffin” and into society with the invention of synthetic blood, but obviously that’s going to be messy and weird for everybody. And it is! Anna Paquin stars as a maybe-part-fae bartender and Stephen Moyer as her vampire situationship. Showrunner Alan Ball (better known for Six Feet Under) brings a wide streak of black humor to the proceedings. I’m pretty sure the actors all know what kind of show they’re in, which is to say there’s a sense of play, especially in the early running, that makes the whole thing a hoot. A certain kind of person will giggle if you shout “SOOKIE!” at a party and iykyk about the scene where Denis O’Hare rips a news anchor’s spine out on live TV. This show really did have everything, and was far better than 2008’s other notable vampire-related release. –DB

Put it on when you find the honest histrionics of Anne Rice’s vampires a bit too much.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

orange is the new blackOrange is the New Black (2013)

A show where they mostly wore khaki

Based on: Piper Kerman’s Orange Is the New Black: My Year in a Women’s Prison (2010)
Subgenres: Worst Places to See Your Ex • The Prison Industrial Complex is Evil • Cosplay Ideas for Large Groups

 

Being incarcerated alongside the ex who sent you to prison isn’t just a cruel joke of the universe: It actually happened to Piper Kerman, who transported dirty money on exactly one occasion for her former girlfriend, drug smuggler Alex Vause. Thank goodness she wrote a memoir about it, so it could become this show. Orange Is The New Black’s humor, heart, and earnest examination of the American prison system made it one of the earliest hits of the streaming era, and as its scope expanded from Piper to focus on its sprawling ensemble cast, its saturation only increased. Everyone watched this show. Your mom. Your co-worker. The worst guy you know probably had a (very bad) opinion about one of the most controversial character deaths of the time. –OS

Put it on when you definitely want to laugh (but maybe also cry).

See also:

Kate Mulgrew on the Work of Waiting, in Acting and in Life • Blurring the Lines Between Criminal Justice and Popular Culture

*

*

MATCHUP:

Sherlock (16) vs. The Queen’s Gambit (8)

******************************************

sherlockSherlock (2010)

The game is on

Based on: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s The Sherlock Holmes stories (1887-1927)
Subgenres: Former Tumblr Teen Bait • They Should Have Kissed • Seeing the Mind Palace

 

For those who frequented certain corners of the early 2010s internet, it was entirely possible to know everything about Sherlock without ever having seen it. This take on the character situates Holmes in a contemporary setting and employs superimposition alongside slick editing and undersaturated cinematography to visualize his deductions. But even though memes about Benedict Cumberbatch’s name are long out of style, appreciation of Sherlock endures, demonstrating more than anything why, over 100 years after Conan Doyle published the first Sherlock Holmes stories, we still care about Holmes and Watson. –OS

Put it on when you want to feel smarter than you actually are.

See also:

Not My Sherlock • A Literary Feud is Afoot! • The Real Sherlock Holmes: How an Edinburgh Doctor Inspired Doyle’s Detective

••••••••••vs••••••••••

The Queen’s Gambit (2020)

Sex, drugs, and the Sicilian Defense

Based on: Walter Tevis’s The Queen’s Gambit (2003)
Subgenres: Lockdown Hit • Child Prodigy • High Functioning Addicts • Mad Men School of Cool Period Details • Redownloading the Chess App

 

Like Tiger King and that Bo Burnham special, the terrible months of COVID lockdown had some surprising pop culture hits. The Queen’s Gambit was one bright light, a coming of age story about a talented chess player battling addiction and patriarchy. The show was fun and filled with lots of nice 50s and 60s details. The big complaint from fans of the book is that Anya Taylor-Joy is too attractive to play the main character as written; Sarah Miller wrote in The New Yorker that though the “Actors Are Too Hot Hill is a silly place to die,” the adaptation suffers from this radical reimagining of the character. Whether the orphan chess prodigy could moonlight as a model or not, The Queen’s Gambit has gripping writing that makes good use of the tense, cliffhanger-a-minute pacing of a streaming show. And it was kind of nice during COVID lockdown to see a glamorous but tragic version of boozy board game players, when I was also spending a lot of time drinking beer and playing Ticket To Ride online. –JF

Put it on when you want to see the whole board.

See also:

If, like the rest of us, you’re suddenly into chess now, here are some books you should read.

*

MATCHUP:

Station Eleven (5) vs.Watchmen (4)

******************************************

Station Eleven (2021)

Post-apocalyptic theater kids against the world

Based on: Emily St. John Mandel’s Station Eleven (2015)
Subgenres: COVID Flashbacks • Beauty After the End • Gael García Bernal Siempre

 

A flu pandemic destroys civilization (yikes) and a traveling theater company makes their way through the ruins. This was a high budget adaptation of a beloved novel, and one that sparked a lot of Opinions: The liberties taken with the book tighten up some of the relationships, which mostly works on screen, though some thought they rendered some of the book’s ambiguities a bit too pat. Either way, the show looks great and the acting and pacing are enthralling—it’s hitting all the prestige TV high notes. And the writing grabs for your heart strings—the response from your tear ducts depends on your taste for melodrama.

But the show’s main assertion about the power of art gets me every time. This is a show about why you reach for the same book at a tough moment. The things we turn to when we need escape or solace become part of how we understand and remember our lives, and there are few other shows that gets at this nuanced way that art entwines itself into our being. –JF

Put it on when you need to cry remembering your favorite childhood book.

See also:

Don’t Worry, Station Eleven Isn’t Really a Pandemic Story • Every Coming-of-Age Story is an Apocalypse Story • What Kind of Pandemic Storytelling Do We Actually Need?

••••••••••vs••••••••••

watchmenWatchmen (2019)

A sequel? A remix? The best comic book series ever?

Based on:  Alan Moore’s Watchmen (but he doesn’t think so) (1986-87)
Subgenres: A Perfect Season of Television • Edgelord Misunderstandings • Commentary on America • Reznor/Ross Soundtracks • Alternate Universes

 

I was suspicious of this show before it aired. Alan Moore, infamous grump about adaptations of his properties, disavowed the whole thing (although who can blame him for feeling nervy after Zach Snyder’s… questionable film adaptation of the original comic) and I wasn’t sure about how I felt about white creators using the Tulsa Race Massacre to open the whole series. But the first episode alone turned me around, setting off an absolute must-see run of nine episodes that pull the Watchmen story forward and demanded (in 2019!) that we come to better terms with the white sheets in the closets of even those we thought might be good people. What does it mean for cops to wear masks and hide their identities? What else can masks hide? Whatever happened to Dr. Manhattan? What on Earth(…) is going on with Jeremy Irons? If the opening episode’s careful set-up and the spectacular Trent Reznor/Atticus Ross score doesn’t hook you, promise me you’ll stick around at least til Jean Smart pulls out the Dr. Manhattan dildo. –DB

Put it on when you want to be reminded of superhero stories that aren’t totally Marvel-ed out.

See also:

Everything You Need to Know About the World of Watchmen • The Best Reporters in Comic Book History

*

MATCHUP:

The Underground Railroad (6) vs. Shogun (3)

******************************************

the underground railroadxThe Underground Railroad (2021)

Speculative American history from an auteur

Based on: Colson Whitehead’s The Underground Railroad (2016)
Subgenres: Barry Jenkins! • American Sins • Magical Realism

 

Whitehead’s book is a difficult act to follow. The novel won every major award and was the kind of critical and commercial success that marked it as an undeniable artistic achievement. It also came out in 2016, when American readers, I think, wanted a reminder of our ancestors’s righteous struggles. We had attempted to redeem ourselves in the past, and had repudiated the ugliness baked into the American experiment. Our current sins, perhaps, wouldn’t be forever.

So much to say, only a director like Barry Jenkins could do justice to both the real history and stakes of Whitehead’s novel, while also beautifully translating the magical realism. Along with a stellar cast, Jenkins crafted an artful, difficult miniseries that pays homage to the original text while also pushing at its borders. Unfortunately, it debuted in spring 2021, early in the Biden years, when many people seemed ready to “get back to brunch.” A show this profoundly heavy and provocative didn’t seem to fit the cultural moment, and was unfairly ignored by many viewers. If you missed it, trust me when I say it’s well worth your time. –JF

Put it on when you want to watch something that feels like cinema.

See also:

Barry Jenkins’ Underground Railroad is Even More Challenging Than the Novel • What I Learned from a Close Read of All of Colson Whitehead’s Work • Read an Excerpt From The Underground Railroad

••••••••••vs••••••••••

shogunShogun (2024)

A stranger fumbling in a strange land, with swords

Based on: James Clavell’s Shogun (1975)
Subgenres: Memed • Subtitles • Epic Battles * Chaotic White Boys • Studying the Blade

 

Just when you thought there was no juice left in “epic prestige historical dramas,” Shogun arrived. The show is huge, with something for everyone: political turmoil, grand battles, and even lighter, fish out of water humor. The story is big too, following the chaotic fallout after the Dutch arrive in a Japan on the verge of the Shogunate Restoration. It’s hard to find a weak link: Shogun is gorgeous, well written, and superbly acted, particularly Anna Sawai, and Hiroyuki Sanada, who plays Lord Toranaga with a quiet, self-assured power. Full of rich texture and detail, the adaptation remains true to the 1975 Clavell novel, especially its gritty and grounded humanity. In every way it exceeds the 1980s adaptation.

Why then isn’t Shogun even higher in our seeding? There’s a way in which the show hews too close to the prestige formula, perhaps, instead of chancing any riskier innovation. But with two more seasons starting production soon, there’s plenty of time for the already excellent Shogun to transcend the expected TV rhythms. –JF

Put it on when you miss studying abroad.

*

MATCHUP:

Mindhunter (7) vs. Wolf Hall (2)

******************************************

Mindhunter (2017)

 Brief interviews with hideous men

Based on: John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker’s Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit (2017)
Subgenres: Serialized Serial Killers Stories • Washed-Out Color Palettes • Grotesques and Their Wicked Ways • The Male Loneliness Epidemic

 

Ah, Mindhunter, the show that dared to ask the question: “What if Zodiac was 20 hours long and somehow even creepier?” David Fincher’s grimly compelling, uncommonly restrained murder show—based on the FBI profilers who pioneered the study of psychopathic killers in the 70s and 80s—was taken from us too soon, but it was fun (I use the term “fun” incredibly loosely) while it lasted. Holden Ford (Groff) is the hotshot loner savant who burrows into the heads of America’s most prolific murderers. Bill Tench (McCallany) is his gruff but bighearted family man partner. Wendy Carr (Torv) is the unflappable closeted lesbian psychologist who completes the basement-dwelling trio. Every Monster of the Week encounter is hold-your-breath stuff, with a particularly memorable performance by Cameron Brittan as the gargantuan “Co-ed Killer” Ed Kemper. –DS

Put it on when you wish your spouse would stop trying to initiate sex while you’re busy staring at your conspiracy board.

See also:

Meet the Forensic Expert Behind Mindhunter

••••••••••vs••••••••••

wolf hallWolf Hall (2015)

The King and I

Based on: Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall (2009)
Subgenres: Milord and Milady Drama • Ye Olde Case Law • Divorced Guy Problems • Stiff Upper Lip

 

Cards on the table: Hilary Mantel is one of my favorite writers of all time, so Wolf Hall occupies a weird space for me. On the one hand, there is no way a television show can exceed the experience of reading the books, and on the other hand, I’m thrilled any time I get to revisit Mantel’s stories.

Luckily, the first season of Wolf Hall is exquisite: patient, cinematic, and subtly acted. Mark Rylance, Damian Lewis, and Claire Foy are all different flavors of calculating, and the conniving dance they’re locked into is mesmerizing. So much is communicated in looks, many hard to discern in the low lighting or obscured by the distance of court and class. It’s an unsettled, quietly tense show that steadily heightens the arcs of each main character, who get what they want but at tremendous cost. Just incredible writing in the first season, which lands an emotionally satisfying ending even if you know where these real historical events are headed.

The second season, alas, loses its footing. The next two books in Mantel’s trilogy are excellent and I applaud the impulse to adapt them, but returning ten years later with the same cast is more than a little dissonant. Still, the first season is good enough to put this show almost at the top of the pack all by itself. –JF

Put it on when you are thinking of going back to school to get your law degree.

See also:

How My Friend Hilary Mantel Got Inside People’s Minds • Diplomacy Noir • How Much Actual History Do You Need for a Historical Novel?

*

 

*

MATCHUP:

Brideshead Revisited (1) vs. My Brilliant Friend (8)

******************************************

Brideshead Revisited (1981)

We have always remembered when we lived in the castle

Based on: Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (1945)
Subgenres: Teddy Bears • Stiff Upper Lip • Everything Changed During the War • Drugs, Booze & Generational Privilege • Debating Catholicism

 

Evelyn Waugh’s observant humanism was always in interesting tension with his sublimated (then blatant) conservatism. His best book, Brideshead Revisited, is nostalgic for aristocracy but clear eyed about its sins, mining the tensions between class values and personal connection. So much to say, this eleven episode miniseries succeeds by faithfully and reverently adapting the novel to the screen—this is about as much of a one-to-one translation from the page as you can imagine, with most of the dialogue coming directly from Waugh. The friendship that unfolds over a few decades before WWII between Charles Ryder and the rich Lord Sebastian Flyte of Brideshead Castle is subtly acted by Jeremy Irons and Anthony Andrews. The rest of the cast is great too, and they’re allowed to mope and emote around beautiful location shoots. Laurence Olivier makes an appearance, as one might expect, and of course actor Peter Bull’s teddy bear named Delicatessen stuns as Aloysius. It’s a wonderful TV classic. –JF

Put it on when you are wondering if you should reach out to an old friend.

See also:

How Campus Novels Reveal the Power—and Danger—of Pure Ideas • Not Far From Brideshead: On the Sad Glitter of Oxford Between the Wars

••••••••••vs••••••••••

my brilliant friendMy Brilliant Friend (2018)

Female friendship, the Italian way

Based on: Elena Ferrante’s The Neapolitan quartet (2012-15)
Subgenres: Gorgeously Shot • 🤌🤌🤌 • Nino Sarratore Sucks In Every Medium • Do We Think Ferrante Had a Secret Cameo?

 

If you’re reading this, I probably don’t have to remind you of the phenomenon that was Ferrante Fever. There was a brief span when it seemed like everyone was reading them—I was simultaneously texting my mom and my guy friends about Lenù and Lila. So it was a bit surprising to me that this visually striking adaptation didn’t make a bigger splash. Maybe it was the subtitles. A lot of people seemed to feel like that the show was almost too beautiful—the colors and shots are frequently arresting, putting Naples front and center in the story—and worse, too slow. But like the source text, this is an adaptation that rewards patience. –JF

Put it on when you can’t afford a ticket to Europe.

See also:

My Brilliant Friend is the Kind of TV We Need Right Now: Slow • “Wade Into the Muck With Me.” On Reading and Re-Reading Elena Ferrante • Language is the True Protagonist of My Brilliant Friend’s Third Season • Before the Neapolitan Quartet, There Was Sula

*

MATCHUP:

Agatha Christie’s Poirot (12) vs. Lonesome Dove (4)

******************************************

Agatha Christie’s Poirot (1989)

Belgian stereotyping with a side of murder

Based on: Agatha Christie’s “Poirot” novels (1920-75)
Subgenres: Murder Follows the Protagonist • Really Good Tea Sets • Mid-Series Genre Shift

 

Agatha Christie’s Poirot ran for almost 25 years, went through at least two major shifts in tone and format, and appears to have guest starred every notable actor in the UK at least once. But there was only ever one Poirot: David Suchet, in what remains the most iconic take yet on Christie’s Belgian investigator. In Suchet’s hands, Poirot’s fussy neuroses go from comic to pathetic from moment to moment, while Poirot’s intelligence becomes a warm, empathetic curiosity about the people around him. However much Suchet’s Poirot preens and waxes his elaborate mustache, we can always see his little gray cells working away. –CG

Put it on when you are prepared to Google at least one murder suspect per episode to confirm that the actor really did become a movie star ten years later.

See also:

Agatha Christie is the best-selling novelist in history.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

lonesome doveLonesome Dove (1989)

 A story as big as that Montana sky

Based on: Larry McMurtry’s Lonesome Dove (1985)
Subgenres: Horses • Someday I’ll Leave This Town • Yeehaw • Walking Off Into The Sunset • Tears Falling on a Dusty Trail

 

There have been a lot of think pieces over the last year about the Lonesome Dove-aissance. It’s a great book, the kind of lengthy classic that reads as fast as a beachy thriller, and has been a sensation since it was published—it only took four years after publication to make it to the screen. The four episode, made for TV miniseries was an instant hit too, breaking all kinds of viewership records and raking in the awards, thanks in part to its top-tier cast: Tommy Lee Jones, Diane Lane, Robert Duvall, Danny Glover, Anjelica Huston, and many more. The only person who didn’t like it was Larry McMurtry himself; after the adaptation aired, he famously began to regret how the book had landed as “a kind of Gone with the Wind of the West.”

“I thought I had written about a harsh time and some pretty harsh people,” he said, “but to the public at large, I had produced something nearer to an idealization.” That’s TV for you! –JF

Put it on when you think you’d look good in a cowboy hat.

See also:

The Book That Changed My Life • What If I’m Actually a Character in a Larry McMurtry Novel? • Orphans, Institutions, and Adventures Out West: Five Books Featuring Unconventional Families

*

MATCHUP:

Big Little Lies (11) vs. M*A*S*H (3)

******************************************

Big Little Lies (2017)

The Witherspoon book-to-TV machine’s biggest hit

Based on: Liane Moriarty’s Big Little Lies (2014)
Subgenres: Murder-Mystery • Wealthy California Moms • Scary Men • Scarier Kids

 

Whether you’re the targeted consumer of a Liane Moriarty novel or not is irrelevant when it comes to Big Little Lies. The show was a sacred union of Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman, Shailene Woodley, Zoe Kravitz, and Laura Dern, all in the roles they were destined to play. That is: over-the-top-wealthy helicopter mothers who intermittently spend their time having anguished conversations with their husbands, their children, each other, and then gazing off into the ocean while drinking chilled wine. Each actress is so compelling and addictive to watch, with their domestic and social lives in such complicated and realistic turmoil, we almost don’t need the show to also be a murder-mystery of the highest caliber, and yet it is that too. We watched with bated breath to find out each and every detail of the murder, for this mystery takes the medium one step further: not only do we not know who the murderer is, we don’t even know who was killed. Even once you know those details, the show begs for a rewatch. The actors, the music, the money, the minutia, the Monterey Bay setting: all of it adds up to a soothingly impeccable version of an hour long drama. –JH

Put it on when you need to remember wealth ≠ happiness.

See also:

Women Can Lead Lives of Quiet Desperation Too

••••••••••vs••••••••••

mashM*A*S*H (1972)

Antics among atrocities

Based on: Richard Hooker’s MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors (1968)
Subgenres: War is Bad • Wisecracking is Fun

 

Iconic anti-war sitcom *M*A*S*H* challenged what a television comedy was supposed to look like, layering drama and genuine commentary with its humor. A spinoff of the 1970 Robert Altman film, which was adapted from the Hooker novel, it ran for 11 seasons and its finale was, at the time of airing, the most watched television episode in American broadcast history. Set during the Korean War, it more obviously paralleled and criticized American involvement in Vietnam. Now considered classic TV, there’s a reason appreciation for *M*A*S*H* endures over 50 years after its premiere. –OS

Put it on when you need a history lesson with personality.

*

MATCHUP:

Olive Kitteridge (10) vs. Pride & Prejudice (2)

******************************************

olive kitteridgeOlive Kitteridge (2014)

A family saga slowly told

Based on: Elizabeth Strout’s Olive Kitteridge (2008)
Subgenres: Fictional Maine • Family Sagas • Ann Dowd Can Do Anything

 

Olive Kitteridge does right by its Pulitzer-winning source material: the interlinked stories of the book become a coherent, patient miniseries. I imagine the simplest choice would have been to divide the narrative into distinct episodes, like the book does, but the adaptation cleverly weaves everything together. Though she’s not the main character per se, Olive is the most prominent and recurring resident of Crosby, Maine. She’s played expertly by Frances McDormand, who is able to sell the glimmers of love and hope behind Olive’s crabby exterior. There are some deeply tragic moments in this story but the humor sticks out most in my mind: I love the bizarre set piece of Olive and her husband fighting while they’re being held hostage. It takes talented actors to ground a scene like that. –JF

Put it on when you want to feel like you’re watching a novel.

See also:

Six of the Best Bad Women in Fiction • Writing “Women of a Certain Age.” A Roundtable on Crafting Older Female Characters in Fiction • Romance Finely Aged: On the Unique Dynamic of Older Couples

••••••••••vs••••••••••

pride and prejudicePride and Prejudice (1995)

Thee Pride and Prejudice

Based on: Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice (1813)
Subgenres: Bonnets • Yearning • Water Cooler Fodder When There Were Still Water Coolers • Every Scene of the Novel

 

Has there ever been a TV mini series as beloved as this BBC charmer? Adapting one of Austen’s most beloved novels with scrupulous fidelity, Pride and Prejudice was an immediate sensation on both sides of the Atlantic when it premiered in 1995. Bright-eyed Jennifer Ehle rode her performance as Elizabeth Bennet straight into an acclaimed theater career, while Colin Firth’s turn as the saturnine Mr. Darcy was so magnetic it transformed him into a Hollywood leading man almost overnight. In the years since, there’s been more than one Pride and Prejudice on screens both big and little. But for purists, there’s never been anything to touch the classic. –CG

Put it on when you have a hankering for charged flirting in a drawing room.

See also:

Martin Amis on the Genius of Jane Austen (and What the Adaptations Get Wrong) • Every Mr. Darcy* Ranked • Why We Still Love Mr. Darcy, 200 Years Later

*

 

******************************************

 We’re really moving along now! See you tomorrow for the round of 16.

 

The Enduring Genius of Janet Malcolm

0

Read Morejanet malcolm with cat

By the time I learned who Janet Malcolm was, it turned out that I had been circling her for some time. What I mean is that I had known about her work—I had read some of her articles in college classes and for pleasure, had had her books recommended to me by more than one beloved professor—but I just never had any reason to note the byline. If you are among those in the know, this may sound ridiculous to you. When you know of Janet Malcolm you spot traces of her everywhere. You understand that she was a titan of American letters—a longtime staff writer for The New Yorker, a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters, a National Book Award finalist, and the list goes on. You register her far-reaching influence. You can see that she was running circles around everyone else. But if you don’t know to look for her name, it is easy to miss.

This was by design. To say that Malcolm was disinterested in being a celebrity is an understatement. She was actively opposed to the idea. While other prominent writers in her milieu—Susan Sontag, Joan Didion, Renata Adler—became recognizable names and faces, the literary It Girls of their day, Malcolm generally did what she could to stay out of view. She didn’t like to talk about her work. She almost never posed for photos, sat for interviews, or did readings. When she and Didion both celebrated their eightieth birthdays in 2014, New York Magazine wanted to run a joint tribute, and Malcolm said no. Even for a rare appearance, a live conversation in 2012 with the writer Katie Roiphe at NYU for The Paris Review, she insisted on reading a pre-written interview transcript aloud rather than speaking off the cuff. “There was something sublime and deranged about this arrangement,” Roiphe later wrote of the event, “but there was also an elegance to her solution: She had found a way to be both present and not, at the same time.”

Above all, she was fixated on the realities of a writer’s subjectivity long before it was commonplace or fashionable for journalists to interrogate the limits of their own perspective.

There are a number of possible explanations for Malcom’s notorious reticence. A woman, a Jew, and an émigré, she was always a member of the minority, though she didn’t dwell on it. She was also a late bloomer: She didn’t publish her first piece of reported long-form journalism, the kind of writing for which she would become known, until 1978, when she was forty-three years old. And then in 1984, Jeffrey Masson, a Sanskrit scholar, a psychoanalyst, and the subject of Malcolm’s In the Freud Archives, sued her for libel, tarnishing her image even though she eventually won the suit. Concurrent to the legal battle—which lasted over a decade, all in—Malcolm published The Journalist and the Murderer, a long piece of reporting about another journalist who was sued by a subject. The opening sentence of Malcolm’s piece—“Every journalist who is not too stupid or too full of himself to notice what is going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible”—quickly became one of journalism’s most controversial and oft-quoted lines (a reviewer once referred to it as Malcolm’s Law). Her peers went berserk, both because she had come for their profession and because she had neglected, at first, to acknowledge the obvious overlap between her choice of subject and the events of her own life. They called her a tattler, a backstabber, a cop, “journalism’s school slut.” As soon as she was able, Malcolm retreated from the public eye.

But she never stopped writing. In fact, the years when Malcolm was facing Masson in court and taking a beating from members of her profession in the pages of their publications were the most productive years of her writing life. She profiled artists, wrote laser-focused criticism of books and photography, and published multiple long-form journalistic pieces that would come to be recognized as exemplars of the genre. Her work shared some DNA with the New Journalists, who used literary techniques such as inserting themselves into their work to write nonfiction as vivid as fiction, but went somewhere else entirely. Thanks, perhaps to a long-standing interest in psychoanalysis, she was intensely focused on the inner lives of her subjects, the psychological dynamics playing out in the scenes she witnessed, and the morality of the work she was doing.

Above all, she was fixated on the realities of a writer’s subjectivity long before it was commonplace or fashionable for journalists to interrogate the limits of their own perspective. Regardless of the subject, each piece she wrote was also an examination of how people tell stories—about themselves and on behalf of others—and of the ethical morass of any act of narrativizing. In her writing, she explored these questions with a provocative sure-footedness that made her easy to criticize during the years she was taking the stand, and a hero to many—a true writer’s writer—in the decades that followed.

When I first became properly aware of Malcolm in 2018, this thorny metacommentary was a source of intrigue. She was there but not there, famous but also shrouded in mystery. At the time I was a student at Yale University, fascinated by journalism, Freudians, and the detritus of other people’s lives—three varyingly niche interests I shared, as it turns out, with Malcolm. In 2013, she had sold her papers to Yale’s Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library. But when I started studying them five years later, they were just being opened to the public, making me one of the first people to spend time in the Janet Malcolm archive.

Each day that year, I descended into the library’s subterranean reading room—a place Malcolm also spent time in the early 2000s while working on a book about Alice B. Toklas and Gertrude Stein—to sift through the contents of another messy box of her papers. I learned to read her handwriting with ease and grew familiar with the turns of phrase she would use in short faxes to friends or the stern tone she would take when an editor had gone against her wishes. Above all, I learned to be patient while examining overfilled boxes of messy, confusing, repetitive, and frequently boring papers.

Accordingly, Malcolm acolytes will tell you that she is everywhere and nowhere within her work.

Much of the materials—which Malcom had prepared for their sale to Yale—seemed, at first, to pertain strictly to business. But the more time I spent in the archive, the more her personal life started to seep in around the edges. I found official documents from her childhood—Czech papers, her certification of American Citizenship, her middle-school report cord, stowed in an unsuspecting envelope between thick folders of miscellaneous correspondence. I stumbled on carefully typed instructions for the house sitter about how to adequately look after her prized plants and cats. I began to see how draft upon draft of the same page or paragraph (Malcom would frequently try writing out a passage four or five different ways in order to even start to get it right) tells a story of the writer at work.

Above all, I became obsessed with the letters. Malcolm understood the appeal: “Only when he reads a subject’s letters does the biographer feel he has come fully into his presence,” she once wrote.  As with the rest of her papers, much of the correspondence in Malcolm’s archive was nominally about work. But even letters exchanged with a peer or editor contained moments of quiet revelation. While she appears in her published writing as a terrifyingly sharp, often dispassionate observer of other people—one critic wrote of her journalism, “Not content simply to tell her subjects’ stories, she believes it is a writer’s responsibility to judge them”—notes to and from sources reveal her humanity.

She was genial. She was interested in her subjects’ day-to-day lives. She cared deeply about what they thought of her writing while also recognizing that she couldn’t control their reactions. Though she wrote at length about the fraught ethics of the journalist-subject relationship, she could get beyond it: It was not uncommon for her to stay in touch with people after she was done writing about them. Some even became good friends.

My experience of combing Malcolm’s archive was as intimate as it was unsettling. I grew fiercely attached to her while working on a project that I sensed she would not be happy about. Much of Malcolm’s writing touches on the strange voyeurism and uncanny attachments that develop when you’re writing about someone else. “Biographical research leads to a kind of insufferable familiarity,” she once observed in an essay about the Bloomsbury Group. Or, of the genre on the whole, “It is an unholy practice, the telling of a life story that isn’t one’s own on the basis of oppressively massive quantities of random, not necessarily reliable information.” Reading these words at night after a day spent poring over her drafts, letters, invoices, and assorted scribbles was at once funny and discomfiting. I could see, from my own experience doing the thing Malcolm purported to hate in her own archive, that she as almost certainly right.

Adding another layer of strangeness to the whole exercise was that Malcolm was, at the time, still alive and well, going about her life in New York City, and not just a disembodied voice on the page in my imagination. I just didn’t have access to her. Early on in my research, I had written to Malcolm asking if she would speak to me as part of the project for which she had become my subject. It should come as no surprise that she rebuffed my request. “I’m so sorry, but I must say no to your proposal of talking with me about my work,” she replied. “I just never do that. I feel my writing must speak for itself. As Isadora Duncan said, ‘If I could talk about it, I wouldn’t have to dance it.’ ” This was a version of the same response Malcolm gave to the vast majority of her would-be interviewers: The work speaks for itself. And if she’s not speaking, it also speaks for her. Okay, I figured, why not take her at her word? What does the work say about the writer behind it?

As in her archive, one must dig a little to find Malcolm in her own writing. Until the very end of her career, she almost entirely avoided writing squarely about herself. As she once remarked to a friend, “No, I don’t think I will ever do a book in which I have to do all the talking—too strenuous. “Even when she finally wrote a memoir in the last years of her life, she structured it around a series of family photographs, which she appraised with her characteristic degree of remove.

Accordingly, Malcolm acolytes will tell you that she is everywhere and nowhere within her work. She pops up or interjects when you least expect it: to mention her psychiatrist father in passing, to inquire after the well-being of a cat. The critic James Wood once tellingly said that she moves around her subjects “like a janitor at an orgy.” She regarded everyone with the same cutting, distanced gaze. But she didn’t exempt herself. Every piece she wrote about someone else—which is to say, nearly every piece she wrote—told two stories simultaneously: the story of the subjects, and the story, always fraught and often veiled, of her retelling.

For example, in The Silent Woman, her 1994 account of the writers jockeying to tell the story of Slyvia Plath, Malcolm lays out the uneasy positions of Plath’s many biographers, friends-turned-memoirists and even a former flame before revealing, some seventy pages in, her bias  toward on in particular. “My narrative would be revisionist,” she wrote, implicating herself in the very problem—that is, the inability of any biographer to see her subject clearly—that she was diagnosing.

Or, near the end of her 2017 profile of the liberal political journalist Rachel Maddow, Malcolm leaves in a strange exchange wherein she becomes fixated on a distant relative to whom the news anchor has little, if any, connection. Then she lays the rhetorical move bare to her subject, and thus to her readers: “When I told Rachel of my fascination with Ben Maddow and of my feeling that by inserting him into a piece that was supposed to be about her I was imitating her forays into left field, she nodded in agreement. “It seems as inevitable as it is wrong that Malcolm should try her subject’s reportorial style on for size.

Once, upon reading Malcolm’s 1999 legal drama The Crime of Sheila McGough, the writer Ruth Gay, a close friend, observed appreciatively that “the world according to Janet” served as a kind of “compass” for the story. “Someday,” she wrote, “I hope you will write more directly about ‘the world according to Janet.’ I feel as if I am always just getting tantalizing glimpses. And I would like to know more.” Reading Malcolm’s writing in search of Malcolm herself feels something like this. You see just enough of her to glimpse a personality (observant, clever, biting), but the details are sparse enough that you are always hungry for more. She’s not hiding but she’s not firmly there. She’s dancing around the margins. She’s reminding you that you can never trust your narrator, that journalists care more about the story than the people who populate it (and who make their work possible), but she isn’t exactly spelling out where she sits in that unholy equation or why she has chosen to devote her life to work that she evidently thinks is so riddled with flaws.

Still, Malcolm’s choice to position herself this way says plenty on its own. By making the journalistic “I” its own obviously and self-consciously subjective character, she was reminding her readers that every creative choice in a give piece of her writing—each detail recorded, letter quoted, subject interviewed, question asked—is a product of her position, not just as a writer, but as a person in the world. “We are all in our work,” she once pointed out to a wary subject mid-interview. “What I write here will probably have a lot more to do with me than it does with [other] people. “As she became more established, this trademark posture became a source of fascination unto itself, prompting curious readers to look at, rather than away from, their strange and unreachable narrator. “With its subtext of ‘Look at me looking at me looking at them,’ it isn’t voyeuristic, as Malcolm proposes, but an act of a more solitary sort,” one reviewer wrote of The Silent Woman. “It leaves me wanting a biography of the brilliant but unreliable Janet Malcolm.”

Spending time with a person whose writing I knew so well was both disorienting and wonderful.

The first writing of Malcolm’s I read was her work on psychoanalysis, and because of this I had the idea of transference lodged in my mind from my earliest encounters with her. Here’s Malcolm on the subject: “The concept of transference at once destroys faith in personal relations and explains why they are tragic: we cannot know each other. We must grope around for each other through a dense thicket of absent others. We cannot see each other plain.”

With this in mind, I began to see the facts of Malcolm’s life cropping up across her work, not just in those moments where she employed the first person but also in the details she chose to highlight about her subjects, and even in the stories she chose to tell. It seemed undeniable that writing about other people was a way for her to parse aspects of her own life and mind. I became fixated on the idea that the people Malcolm wrote about and was close to overlapped with certain identities she embodied herself: the émigré, the humorist, the photographer, the shrink watcher, the defendant, the writer, the artist, and the archivist.

Malcolm was hardly oblivious to what was going on here. “How can one see all the ants on the planet when one is wearing the blinders of narrative?” she asked in The Silent Woman. The problem of the nonfiction writer’s subjectivity was one of her central fixations. Still, she couldn’t help but partake. Just look at The Silent Woman. The premise of the book is paradoxical in a classically Malcolmian way: It is simultaneously a condemnation of the genre of biography and a literary biography unto itself. In it, she likens the biographer to a burglar, describing the way they rifle through the detritus of someone else’s life—notably, their papers—picking and choosing details as they see fit to tell a story that is almost entirely one of their own making. She’s almost imploring her readers to read her work the same way.

At the end of The Silent Woman, Malcolm visits the home of a source named Trevor Thomas and finds it to be monstrously, unbearably cluttered: appliances and objects are strewn everywhere, the kitchen so jammed full that there is no room left in it to prepare a meal. She comes to see the house as a metaphor for the entire project of writing. “This is the way things are, the place says. This is unmediated actuality, in all its multiplicity, randomness, inconsistency, redundancy, authenticity,” she writes, in what could just as easily be a description of an archive. The task of the writer is to clean house, to make sense of an unbearable mess of junk. “But this task of housecleaning (of narrating) is not merely arduous; it is dangerous. There is the danger of throwing the wrong things out and keeping the wrong things in,” she opines. “Once one starts throwing out, it may become hard to stop. It may be better not to start. It may be better to hang on to everything.”  Every piece of writing is ultimately about the writer, what you choose to leave in or throw out. This makes for perilous work. But Malcolm knew from experience that it was also pretty irresistible.

As part of my research, in 2019 I began work on an exhibit of materials from Malcolm’s archive, which would go up in the entry of Yale’s main library that spring. I will admit that I was drawn to the idea of putting on a show in part because of its obvious irony: I would embody the biographer Malcolm took pains to admonish, a writer who burglarizes someone else’s life, puts it on display, and makes it her own. I was sure that Malcolm would hate the exhibit if she ever saw it. I rationalized the project by telling myself she was the one who had sold her papers to Yale. She had to know that they would be used by someone else. And anyway, the odds of her schlepping up to New Haven to see the show seemed pretty slim.

So you can imagine my surprise when I received an email from her out of the blue some months later, bearing the subject line “from Janet Malcolm,” like I wouldn’t clock her AOL email address right away (Despard9, named for one of her cats). She had been to see the show. “I dreaded going to see it,” Malcolm wrote. “I thought it would embarrass me, and instead it delighted me.” Would I like to come over for tea?

Over the two years that followed we met several times and stayed in touch, sharing essays we’d written and books we’d read. Spending time with a person whose writing I knew so well was both disorienting and wonderful. I had not expected that Malcolm would be the type to speak candidly about her friends and family or to ask me about my love life. The first time we met, Malcolm asked me if she seemed in person the way she had in her papers. She did, and I told her so. But as she knew better than anyone, we’re all inventing our own versions of the people we spend time with, in life and in writing, and biographers are among the worst culprits. My research informed these encounters just as my own proclivities and anxieties determined what I looked for when I pored over Malcolm’s papers, and the details I choose to write about now. My rendering of Malcolm is just that: mine.

__________________________________

the absent woman

From The Absent Woman. Used with the permission of the publisher, W.W. Norton and Company. Copyright © 2026 by Eve Sneider

 

Maddow: After Hegseth, watch for impeachment of Trump’s A.G. Todd Blanche

0

Read More

November 9, 2026; 9pm: Rachel Maddow examines a House impeachment push against Pete Hegseth and argues that Todd Blanche’s Justice Department faces a larger accountability test, with lessons from Harry Daugherty and Teapot Dome. She also speaks with Georgia Governor-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms and former FBI official Peter Strzok while tracking unfinished Senate and governor races.

Want more of Rachel? Check out the “Rachel Maddow Presents” feed to listen to all of her chart-topping original podcasts.

To listen to all of your favorite MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.