Home Blog Page 11

Big Ideas, Small Budgets: The November/December Issue of Public Libraries is Here

Read More

The November/December 2026 issue of Public Libraries is now available. In Big Ideas, Small Budgets, we explore what innovation looks like in the day-to-day work of public libraries, from making a space more welcoming to connecting patrons with services they need.

Inside this issue

  • Elevated Library Design on Any Budget — Interior designer Meghan Bentheimer shares ways to make library spaces more welcoming and functional, with advice on where to focus your budget.
  • (Not) Closing the Books — Anthony Aycock looks at how partnerships with legal experts can expand access to legal information and assistance.
  • Small Grants, Big Impact — Justin Dyer explores how libraries use microgrants and community partnerships to bring new ideas to life.

Also in this issue, Aimee Adams looks beyond the familiar 1,000 Books Before Kindergarten model, Catherine Hakala-Ausperk explores how library spaces can encourage play and creativity, and Sara Goek highlights resources for building digital literacy. In The Big Idea, Gretchen Kaser Corsillo makes the case for sustained investment in public libraries.

PLA members and subscribers can read the November/December issue of Public Libraries.

The post Big Ideas, Small Budgets: The November/December Issue of Public Libraries is Here first appeared on Public Libraries Online.

 

Jensen Huang’s Nvidiotic Spy Scandal + Can Dems Pass AI Regulation?

0

Read MoreIt might be the biggest tech scandal of the year, and possibly the most significant intelligence breach since the Cold War. On Sunday, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang admitted to an affair, following reports that Alice Huang, the woman involved, is a suspected Chinese intelligence asset. What happens now to Jensen, to the world’s most important AI company (which has no clear succession plan), and to the fight over U.S.-China AI policy and chip export controls?

Then, Rep. Greg Casar of Texas, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus and one of the most vocal voices on AI regulation in the House, joins us to talk about how Democrats plan to use their new majority to pass AI policy in the new Congress. He explains why he wants to tax AI companies, why he co-wrote a bill with Sen. Bernie Sanders to ban artificial superintelligence, and why he thinks Congress should move to ban recursive self-improvement.

For a transcript of this episode, select the episode on npr.org/machinegods.

You can watch this full episode on YouTube, Spotify or Apple Podcasts. And if you’ve got a question you want us to answer, you can drop us a comment on any of those platforms or email us at hey@machinegods.fm.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

Did comets bring building blocks of life to Earth? Scientists aren’t so sure anymore

0

Read More

The origin of life on Earth remains a mystery. New research shows that comets almost certainly did not bring the chemical building blocks of life to our planet.

Life as we know it is based around carbon chemistry, also known as organic chemistry. Complex organic molecules are the fundamental building blocks of biochemical compounds such as nucleobases, amino acids, sugars and so on that act as the machinery for biochemistry on Earth.

Two big questions are where did this complex chemistry originate? Did these complex organic molecules form on Earth, or were they delivered here from space?

New research led by planetary scientist Richard Anslow of the Institute for Astronomy at the University of Cambridge has now seemingly ruled out comets as the origin of complex organic molecules on Earth.

“Historically, scientists thought that comets were important for the origin of life on Earth, because they carried carbon and nitrogen-bearing molecules, so these giant space snowballs were almost like a ‘get-out-of-jail-free card’ that brought all the molecules a planet would need to seed life,” said Anslow in a statement.

Stripping the romance from the Earth’s turbulent past

Comet impacts on Earth were much more frequent in the first half-billion years of the solar system’s existence, when there were still lots of debris leftover from the formation of the planets.

For over a century comet impacts had been considered a prime suspect in the search for what brought the building blocks of life to Earth. However, while comets bringing the building blocks of life to Earth is “kind of a romantic idea,” according to Anslow, the University of Cambridge researcher added that the team’s results suggest that is highly unlikely.

Anslow and colleagues arrived at this conclusion based upon computer modeling by using the very latest simulations depicting the origin and evolution of comets and their orbits, their interactions with Earth’s atmosphere as they enter it, and of the hypervelocity comet impacts themselves.

In particular, they used the fate of hydrogen cyanide as a proxy for what happens to complex organic molecules in comet impacts. Hydrogen cyanide is frequently found in comets and was even detected in the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS.

A explosive orange impact on a brown fragmented landscape

An artist’s impression of a comet crashing into the early Earth (Image credit: Scarlett White)

The problem is that comets are generally moving at too great a velocity. For organic molecules to survive impact, the impact velocity would have to be below 33,500 miles per hour (15 kilometers per second).

Anslow and his colleagues found that, in general, comets travel too fast and enter Earth’s atmosphere at too sharp an angle for complex organic molecules to survive. Instead, they are mostly vaporized on impact. Even on the rare occasions that the complex organic molecules survived, they were usually not in great enough abundance to provide any meaningful prebiotic chemistry.

“It would really have to be a one-in-a-million occurrence, because not only would you need an impact at just the right speed and just the right angle, you would also need everything to happen after that point, in terms of the concentration and the speed at which the chemical origins of life got going,” said Anslow. “We can’t rule out for certain that it happened that way, but it seems to be a really rare occurrence – at best, a one-off fluke.”

Maybe life on Earth is a fluke

It is not yet known if the origin of life on Earth was a fluke, or whether life is plentiful in the universe, so a fluke occurrence could still have been a trigger for life on our planet.

However, researchers are coming around to alternatives, either that all the pre-biotic chemistry that resulted in life took place on Earth without requiring material from space, or asteroids instead brought those important molecules to Earth.

Scientists have found asteroids to be rich in those molecules – for example, the sample of material brought back by the OSIRIS-REx mission from the near-Earth asteroid Bennu contained all the building blocks of RNA.

However, other planets could have plausibly benefitted from comet impacts. The simulations showed that complex organic molecules in comets would stand a slightly better chance of surviving impacts on Mars, because of the Red Planet’s thinner atmosphere and lower gravity.

“This is not to say it definitely happened on Mars, of course, but it suggests it would be unlikely if it happened on Earth and didn’t happen on Mars,” said Anslow. “Or the other, perhaps more likely, alternative is that it didn’t happen on either planet.”

A glowing orange sphere with seven smaller grey spheres lining up in front of it

The 7 planets circling the star TRAPPIST-1, 3 of which might be able to keep liquid water on its surface. (Image credit: R. Hurt/T. Pyle/NASA)

More intriguing are the possibilities on exoplanets, specifically the peas-in-a-pod multi-planet systems around red dwarf stars such as TRAPPIST-1, where all the planets are bunched up close.

In 2023 Anslow wrote a research paper describing how comets could gravitationally bounce from one planet to the next, losing velocity in the process so that when they crash into one of the planets, they impact is not so severe and complex organic molecules might have a chance to survive.

The team’s research was published on 28 October in Scientific Reports.

 

‘There’s tremendous demand’: Rocket Lab raises price of Neutron launch from $55 million to $70 million

0

Read More

The coming launch bottleneck has ramped up demand for a rocket that has yet to leave the ground.

Rocket Lab announced on Monday (Nov. 9) that it recently raised the price of a Neutron launch from $55 million to $70 million — an increase of more than 25%, for a ride on a rocket that’s set to debut in 2027.

“Launch is extremely constrained, and that is exactly the situation we predicted,” Rocket Lab founder and CEO Peter Beck said on Monday during the company’s third-quarter earnings call. “We saw a pent-up launch market on the horizon, and rather than provide early discounted launches, we set out to deliver a rocket into an environment with extreme demand at full price or higher.”

Rocket Lab is best known for Electron, a workhorse small-satellite launcher that debuted in 2017 and now has 90 orbital missions under its belt. The 59-foot-tall (18 meters) expendable rocket and can haul 660 pounds (300 kilograms) to low Earth orbit (LEO).

Neutron is the company’s entry into the medium-lift market. It features a reusable first stage, stands 141 feet (43 m) tall and can carry 14.3 tons (13 metric tons) of payload to LEO.

Rocket Lab announced Neutron back in 2021 and first targeted a 2024 debut for the vehicle. But various problems have cropped up over the years, pushing things back. Last month, for example, Rocket Lab announced that it was delaying the first Neutron flight from late 2026 into 2027 due to a manufacturing issue (which it says is now under control).

Such setbacks have not dampened demand for Neutron’s services, however. During Monday’s call, Beck revealed that Rocket Lab booked eight Neutron launches during the third quarter of 2026, which ran from July 1 through Sept. 30.

The contracts for those eight flights are worth “a total of roughly 515 million, including multiple missions on a new escalated base price of $70 million,” Beck said. Neutron’s first 16 launches are now sold out, he added, and bookings from here on will be for flights in the 2030s.

“The demand is a function of both a tightening global launch supply and our customers’ confidence that Rocket Lab is the right partner to break the world’s launch bottleneck,” Beck said.

illustration of a large black rocket landing on a ship at sea

Artist’s illustration of Neutron’s first stage coming down for a landing on a ship at sea. (Image credit: Rocket Lab)

That bottleneck is coming in 2028 or so, when SpaceX plans to retire its Falcon 9 rocket. For some perspective, and comparison with Neutron: SpaceX currently charges $74 million for each Falcon 9 launch. The rocket has a reusable first stage and can carry about 25 tons (22.7 metric tons) to LEO.

The medium lifter has been the world’s most prolific rocket for the past few years. In 2025, for example, it flew 165 times — roughly the same number of orbital missions as all other launchers in the world combined. And all 165 of those flights were successful.

But SpaceX is phasing out the Falcon 9 — and its heavy-lift cousin, the Falcon Heavy — nonetheless, shifting all launch work over to its fully reusable Starship megarocket, which can haul more than 100 tons to LEO.

There’s a real worry among folks in the space community that this massive payload capacity won’t be available to them for a while. SpaceX has made it pretty clear that early Starship operations will be geared toward internal priorities — specifically, the buildout of SpaceX’s Starlink V3 broadband network and its Starmind AI data-center constellation.

These will be very big jobs, even for the most powerful rocket ever built. For example, the Starlink V3 megaconstellation will consist of about 100,000 satellites, according to SpaceX founder and CEO Elon Musk. Starship can carry about 60 of these spacecraft to LEO per launch, so just building out the constellation will require about 1,700 liftoffs.

The numbers for Starmind will be even more mind-boggling, for SpaceX wants that constellation to eventually harbor a million satellites.

The coming launch bottleneck should increase demand for Electron as well as Neutron, Beck said during Monday’s call. After all, many small-satellite operators have launched with SpaceX over the years, booking spots on Falcon 9 “rideshare” flights. And those opportunities are now drying up.

“The next logical alternative is of course an Electron, so we see tremendous traction there,” Beck said.

 

Hubble Space Telescope reveals glittering stars with mysterious origins | Space photo of the day for Nov. 11, 2026

0

Read More

The Hubble Space Telescope has captured a breathtaking view of thousands of stars glittering like cosmic jewels in a dazzling display of blue, gold and orange.

But this spectacular scene is far more than just a pretty picture. Some of these stars are almost as old as the universe itself and could hold clues to how our Milky Way formed.

M30 is a globular star cluster located approximately 27,500 light-years from Earth. (Image credit: ESA/Hubble & NASA, M. Libralato, G. Piotto, A. Sarajedini)

What is it?

The exquisite image released by ESA on Nov. 5 shows Messier 30 (M30), a densely packed collection of stars located approximately 27,500 light-years from Earth in the constellation Capricornus.

M30 is a globular cluster, a roughly spherical collection of tens of thousands to millions of stars held together by gravity.

Our Milky Way is home to at least 150 of these ancient stellar gatherings, some of which are estimated to be between 11.5 billion and 13.5 billion years old. For comparison, the universe itself is approximately 13.8 billion years old!

Why is it amazing

Besides looking like a vast cosmic treasure trove glittering across the universe, M30 also has a fascinating story to tell.

Globular clusters are essentially cosmic time capsules. Their ancient stars preserve chemical clues about the conditions that existed when they formed, helping astronomers piece together the Milky Way’s early history.

Astronomers have also discovered that M30, along with several other globular clusters, traverses the Milky Way in the opposite direction to the galaxy’s rotation. This unusual motion raises the intriguing possibility that M30 may not have formed in our galaxy at all. It could have simply been captured by the Milky Way billions of years ago.

 

NASA’s new UVEX space telescope will peer deep into the universe’s most violent events

0

Read More

A new NASA space telescope will study the universe in ultraviolet light to reveal the violent and turbulent events that bubble under what appears to be a cosmic sea of tranquility.

The Ultraviolet Explorer (UVEX) mission, developed by NASA in conjunction with the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), will be the first mission to create deep all-sky maps in ultraviolet light. Thus, when it launches in 2031, UVEX will join new sky-mapping surveys like NASA’s SPHEREx (Spectro-Photometer for the History of the Universe, Epoch of Reionization and Ices Explorer), which scans the cosmos in infrared, and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory, which does the same over the southern hemisphere in visible light, in creating deep-sky maps across a broad swathe of the electromagnetic spectrum.

UVEX’s ultraviolet views will reveal explosive events such as the collisions between ultra-dense stellar corpses called neutron stars and the supernova explosions that mark the deaths of massive stars and the births of neutron stars and black holes. Additionally, the NASA ultraviolet telescope should be able to detect a multitude of low-mass galaxies much closer to the Milky Way than similar galaxies that are currently being observed millions and even billions of light-years away by NASA’s James Webb Space Telescope (JWST).

The $590 million UVEX mission will “advance fundamental frontiers in astrophysics, from understanding the smallest galaxies to diagnosing the aftermath of neutron-star mergers and other cosmic explosions,” the mission’s principal investigator, Caltech physics professor Fiona Harrison, said in an Oct. 27 statement.

“The first major ultraviolet space mission in two decades, UVEX is a bold leap forward in our exploration of the ultraviolet universe,” Caltech President Ray Jayawardhana said in the same statement.

UVEX will paint a picture of cosmic life, death and afterlife

UVEX will benefit from a major leap forward in UV sensitivity thanks to its Caltech-built sensors, which are based on complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) imaging technology. This will help the spacecraft tap into what Harrison described as “the untapped opportunity in the UV.”

UVEX will be uniquely poised to spot millions of nearby, small, and faint galaxies that are teeming with infant stars that emit bright UV light.

“In optical light, it’s very hard to distinguish these nearby galaxies from faraway ones that look similar,” Harrison said. “UV light will make them easier to find.”

UVEX won’t just be investigating the infancy of stars, however. It will also examine the deaths of ancient stars in the form of supernovas.

A fragmented orange sphere in space, surrounded by dozens of bright stars

The supernova relic Pa 30, as seen by the Gemini north telescope. (Image credit: International Gemini Observatory/NOIRLab/NSF/AURA)

Supernovas occur when a massive star runs out of fuel for nuclear fusion and can no longer support itself against the inward push of its own gravity. As the core of the star collapses, its outer layers are blasted outward in cosmic explosions we call supernovas.

This is a process that scientists are keen to understand, as these explosions fling the heavy elements forged during the stars’ lifetimes into surrounding galaxies. This material becomes the building blocks of the next generation of stars, planets, and possibly even life.

UVEX will also investigate what happens to the end products of some supernovas, neutron stars, when they meet and merge.

Two shining blue spheres collide, surrounded by loops of orange fire

An illustration shows two neutron stars colliding and merging. (Image credit: Robert Lea (created with Canva))

Neutron stars contain between one and two times the mass of the sun crammed into a width of around 12 miles (20 kilometers). That means they are composed of matter so dense that, if a teaspoon of it were brought to Earth, it would weigh over 1 billion tons. That’s equivalent to stacking around 9 million adult blue whales on a spoon.

So, when neutron stars in binary systems spiral together and merge, they create an environment so violent that it’s the only place in the universe where scientists are sure that elements heavier than lead, like gold, silver, and platinum, are able to be forged.

Currently, neutron star mergers are detected via ripples in spacetime called gravitational waves. Scientists can then follow up on the aftermath of the mergers by observing them in electromagnetic light, from high-energy gamma rays to low-energy radio waves. Thus, UVEX will add another aspect to the investigation of neutron star collisions and our understanding of where heavy elements originate.

The new space telescope’s maneuverability will allow it to observe these explosive events very shortly after they happen, giving it an advantage over other instruments, including NASA’s long-serving Hubble Space Telescope.

“With UVEX, we will now be able to follow up on gravitational-wave events in ultraviolet light,” UVEX team member and Caltech scientist Mansi Kasliwal said in the same statement. “I can count on two hands how many spectra we have of transient events in their infancy phase with the Hubble Space Telescope. Hubble is, of course, amazing and does have some ultraviolet capabilities, but it cannot rapidly pivot to observe real-time events.”

a bright blue sphere

An illustration of a stripped blue star (Image credit: Robert Lea)

UVEX will also be revolutionary in the study of blue stars that have had their outer layers of hydrogen stripped away by companion stars. These stars offer researchers a unique opportunity to study the interior of stars, which is usually obscured by their outer layers.

“We will be able to see what’s inside the stars,” Kareem El-Badry, an associate professor of astronomy at Caltech and a member of the UVEX team, said in the same statement. “We only know of a small number of stripped stars of this type now. UVEX will find hundreds.”

All of the above elements discussed are the expected discoveries and investigations that UVEX will be involved with. Perhaps even more exciting, however, are the unexpected elements of the universe it will uncover.

“Every time you look at the skies in a new wavelength, you learn something new and unexpected,” El-Badry said.

 

Lit Hub Daily: November 11, 2026

0

Read MoreKurt Vonnegut

TODAY: In 1922, Kurt Vonnegut is born.

 

Public Schools Have a New Crisis: Not Enough Students

0

Read More 

The number of students in America’s public schools is shrinking. In some cases, the declines have been so drastic that districts are facing empty classrooms, painful budget cuts and angry debates about whether to close schools.

Sarah Mervosh, an education reporter at The New York Times, discusses what the enrollment crisis looks like, why it’s happening and how one school district hopes to fix it.

Guest: Sarah Mervosh, an education reporter at The New York Times.

Background reading: 

Photo: Erin Schaff/The New York Times

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. 

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

 

A History of the American Nepo Baby

0

Read Morepolitical nepo babies (hillary clinton, mitt romney, liz cheney) set against the american flag

Perhaps the clearest evidence of Americans’ comfort with aristocracy is their tacit acceptance of the persistent nepotism in modern culture. Nothing better reflects our love of pedigree than the public’s obsession with “nepo babies,” the children of Hollywood stars who ride on their parents’ coattails to become heirlets and starlets. From the Barrymores of early Hollywood to the Hustons; Henry Fonda’s offspring; Kirk and Michael Douglas; the Robert Downeys; Goldie Hawn and Kate Hudson; Blythe Danner and Gwyneth Paltrow; Jerry and Ben Stiller—the nepo baby genealogy grows ever longer.

Their talent is beside the point: they weren’t sifted from the unwashed masses of wannabe actors. The Ochs‑Sulzberger multigenerational family–owned New York Times had to concede there was nothing new in the phenomenon, that “children born into rich, famous and otherwise powerful families have had a leg up in life, inheriting monarchies, business empires, wealth and star power.”

Nepotism, despite its incestuous pattern of marriage within caste, extends far beyond Hollywood. It has infected network news, the publishing industry, and politics. NFL coaches put their sons on the staff. Chris Wallace, son of 60 Minutes anchor Mike Wallace, got his job the old‑fashioned way, which is not to say he lacks competence, but the inside connection is impossible not to see. Other “media legacies” include CNN’s Andrea Koppel (daughter of Ted), legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin (son of a TV producer), and former anchor Chris Cuomo (son and brother of New York governors).

As one critic dryly noted, greed is “natural,” too, but that doesn’t mean we ought to tolerate it.

At Fox, Douglas Harriman Kennedy, a son of Robert F. Kennedy, and Peter Doocy, son of longtime anchor Steve Doocy, carry the torch. NBC earned the nickname “Nepotism Broadcasting Company” thanks to hires like Mika Brzezinski, Ronan Farrow, Willie Geist—and, for a brief, shining moment, Chelsea Clinton. One of the oddest hires at NBC was Luke Russert, all of twenty‑two and fresh out of college in 2008. He was brought in as an election correspondent two months after the untimely death of his well‑liked Meet the Press host father, Tim. In this case, the heir apparent assumed the throne before he’d had any television experience or showed substantive evidence of worth as a political analyst.

In 2003, Adam Bellow, son of Nobel Prize–winning novelist Saul Bellow, wrote an admittedly self‑serving book, In Praise of Nepotism. While he confessed that the intellectual cachet gave him a leg up when he was hired as an editor at Doubleday, which published his book, he still unabashedly marshaled a defense for what he called the “new nepotism.” Deciding for himself that it was far less top‑down than bottom‑up, nepotism struck him as meritocratic in that children of privilege must sink or swim, and could not long coast on inherited advantages. He further insisted that nepotism is so “hardwired” into human nature that it could never truly be eradicated. As one critic dryly noted, greed is “natural,” too, but that doesn’t mean we ought to tolerate it.

Bellow could not prove that there was any meritocracy involved in modern nepotism as there was no way to know (or justify) why children of privilege were being kept on the payroll. The power of their “brand” might be worth more than the bare minimum of competence they had to show. The act of getting one’s foot in the door is nearly everything in the media universe. The film industry and American television have always been about a perception of beauty and how to peddle a familiar face. Where else can a twenty-something model appear fit to star as a city detective?

Politics has always been a family business. George Washington’s nephew Bushrod was named to the Supreme Court by John Adams, setting the tone. Presidential family dynasties followed: John and John Quincy Adams, William Henry Harrison and his grandson Benjamin Harrison, Theodore Roosevelt and his fifth cousin Franklin Roosevelt (whose wife, Eleanor, was Teddy’s niece). More recently, the administrations of George H. W. and George W. Bush were separated by a single president.

The nineteenth‑century spoils system made nepotism explicit, even if it was not always approved. Candidates openly defended such largesse as “taking care of their family.” Nepo baby President Benjamin Harrison ran on the memory of his grandfather’s name and gave his brother a federal appointment. He was publicly taken to task for treating this favor as a “personal privilege” that was too close to a royal prerogative. When in the 1950s The Washington Post coined the term “limousine aristocracy,” it evoked not just wealth but lineage: modern politicians pulling up to the Capitol in luxury cars was the contemporary equivalent of carriages emblazoned with family crests.

The first woman to serve as a state governor, Nellie Tayloe Ross of Wyoming, received her appointment in 1924 after her husband died in office. Until 1976, out of a combined total of ninety‑five female members of Congress, three‑quarters of those who served as senators and half of those in the House were widows when they assumed office—though in most cases not replacing their own husbands. A political woman who was widowed could not so easily be painted as “too ambitious.”

Do they really work twice as hard? The Camelot magic had sprinkled fairy dust over the eyes of journalists.

That dynamic partly explains why Hillary Clinton was attacked for trading on the family name. First Ladies were expected to embrace the “helpmeet” role and concern themselves with beautification and other domestic duties, placing family before personal ambition until their husband died. Among the unflattering nicknames earned during her 2016 presidential run was “Her Royal Clintoness”—a not‑so‑subtle dig at her perceived air of entitlement.

As of 2024, eleven nepo babies sat in the U.S. Congress, six Democrats and five Republicans. Seven of these held the same seat once held by their fathers, and two directly succeeded them. Donald Payne Jr. won a special election in his New Jersey district after his father’s death. Al Gore and Mitt Romney were sons of senators. Before she became senator from Wyoming, Liz Cheney received an appointment as deputy assistant secretary of state (and her husband as chief council for the Office of Management and Budget) during her father’s vice presidency. In 2002, Lisa Murkowski was appointed by her father to fill his former U.S. Senate seat when he became governor of Alaska. At that moment, five other U.S. senators were the sons of former senators. Shelley Moore Capito, U.S. senator from West Virginia, is the daughter of three‑term Governor Arch Moore, whose federal conviction for corruption and resulting prison sentence did nothing to diminish her dynastic advantage. The list goes on.

Donald Trump brought his daughter Ivanka and her husband, Jared Kushner, into the White House, where they wielded an enormous amount of power despite their utter lack of preparation for any of the tasks they commandeered. Less often criticized, but still outlandish, were displays of nepotism involving the Kennedy dynasty, for which appointing relatives was considered a filial duty. John F. Kennedy named his brother Robert to the cabinet as attorney general; then he helped orchestrate his youngest brother Ted’s accession to the Senate seat he vacated, installing a placeholder until Ted turned thirty and became constitutionally eligible.

Though a 1967 law was passed to prohibit this kind of family favoritism, and a long list of laws have been instituted to prohibit nepotism in government contracts, supervisory roles, and appointments, the problem has hardly gone away. Politicians routinely hire colleagues’ relatives to secure allies and skirt restrictions. When Hillary gave up her Senate seat to become President Obama’s secretary of state, presidential daughter Caroline Kennedy, who had not sought a political position before and had never held elected office, allowed her name to be floated as a successor.

Many in the press corps were, not surprisingly, enamored of her. Caroline was praised and flattered for her upbringing, for her glamour, for adding “an infusion of class,” according to New York Times pundit Maureen Dowd. Tripping over the blatant hypocrisy, Dowd excused family privilege in Caroline’s case, though she had ripped into both the Bushes and the Clintons: “Without nepotism, Hillary would be running for the president of Vassar. But then, without nepotism, W. [George W. Bush] would be pumping gas in Midland—and not out of the ground.” After reading all the drooling endorsements of Caroline, one letter to the editor published in the Times joked, “Why not rename the United States Senate the United States House of Peers?”

Others christened Caroline “our tragic national princess,” a “debutante,” and swooned over the magic of the Kennedy name. On National Public Radio, Adam Bellow compared her story to Arthurian legend, saying, “She has drawn her father’s sword from the stone,” offering the Empire State a chance for a “new queen, and her name is Caroline.” Part of her worthiness was what she had imbibed simply in being a Kennedy. It was meant as well to be an understandable picking up of the torch from her then terminally ill uncle Ted. Rationalizing further, Bellow explained, “This kind of motivation is common in dynastic families, and it is as good a reason as any to go into politics. Indeed, it is better than most. Besides, dynastic successors are often driven to exceed expectations and typically work twice as hard in order to earn their advantages.” Do they really work twice as hard? The Camelot magic had sprinkled fairy dust over the eyes of journalists.

In the end, Caroline Kennedy’s bid failed, and she went on to serve as an able U.S. ambassador. But the larger issue goes well beyond Hollywood glamour or Kennedy nostalgia. Nepotism is rooted in the formidable patronage perks that the government has granted, namely, rolling back inheritance taxes and enshrining dynastic trusts. As law professor Ray Madoff argued in “America Builds an Aristocracy,” published in the Times in 2010, the decade of the 1990s saw the strengthening of dynasty trusts in numerous states. Legal changes had eliminated the long‑standing “rule against perpetuities,” which placed a limit of ninety years on the duration of a trust. As Congress increased exemptions on estate taxes, trusts subsidized a new hereditary aristocracy.

One glaring privilege of the dynastic trust is the “spendthrift clause.” This device protects the trust assets of all kinds of nepo babies from creditors and ex‑spouses. Like corporate personhood, which shields the owner’s personal assets from the firm’s creditors, the trust lives on, even if future heirs owe people money. This supercharged trust literally reinvented how entail had kept family wealth consolidated, which Thomas Jefferson took pride in eliminating in the Revolutionary era. These trusts now empowered ancestors to “collude” with the living and perpetuate family wealth and lineage at the same time. Another legal scholar recently noted this “bizarre twist in history.” Though the perpetuities rule that limits the control future generations can exercise over inherited wealth remains on the books in England, it has now disappeared in America, making the United States, in effect, “a more feudal society than the British.”

Here lies the darker dynamic of nepotism. Nepo babies live off the largesse of their parents, obtaining advantage from the eugenic notion of “like breeds like,” that pedigree is a predictor of success. It should surprise no one that a reviewer of Adam Bellow’s book nodded approvingly at the author’s having inherited his father’s “aristocratic profile.” The newest forms of nepotism reaffirm that the feudalistic remnants of patrimony and pedigree are openly flourishing.

__________________________________

aristocracy, american style

From Aristocracy, American Style. Used with the permission of the publisher, Viking. Copyright © 2026 by Nancy Isenberg

 

What is the Best Literary TV Adaptation of All Time? Day Three

0

Read More

Day three! I spent most of yesterday wandering around and trying to process The Leftovers losing in the first round, but after going through the stages of bracket grief (anger, double checking, projecting, anger, thirst, scrolling, anger, and simmering) I think I’m through the worst of it.

Now we’re squarely in the middle of our game, with 16 TV shows remaining after some wild voting yesterday. A surprising number of polls came down to just a few percentage points—Lonesome Dove, Justified, and The Queen’s Gambit were all eliminated, but barely.

Friday Night Lights hit the showers, Lonesome Dove rode off into the sunset, and True Blood had too much garlic.

Big Little Lies got wine drunk and passed out on a gorgeous couch, in a gorgeous house, in front of a gorgeous sunset. Sorry to all the BLL-heads in my life who will be taking this hard.

And Interview with the Vampire beat out Heated Rivalry, which I did not see coming. I thought those hot hockey lads could do no wrong, but seems like the edge has come off of the skate, to use the only non-sex metaphor I can think of about that show.

Lots of great stuff in the mix still, and there are some very fun match-ups today:

– In Cerebral, two great historical fiction shows, Shogun and Wolf Hall, are squaring off. Is the pen mightier than the katana?

– Slow Horses and Say Nothing are up against each other in Carnage, which feels fitting since MI6 and the IRA were 100% out to get each other in real life too.

– In Carnal, we’ve got a toxic-but-hot-relationship-off in Killing Eve vs. Interview with the Vampire. 

– And are the difficulties of love and affection amid changing contexts more interesting when the context is college…or prison? Normal People vs. Orange is the New Black should settle this.

I’m still not positive about which show will win it all. Game of Thrones, Pride & Prejudice, and M*A*S*H all put up big numbers yesterday, so I’m expecting to see at least one of those shows make it to the finals. Are people betting on this? Is Lit Hub on Kalshi? I assume everything’s on Kalshi.

But enough preamble, let’s vote! I’ll see you at the polls!

–James Folta

[Click image to enlarge and zoom]

*

INSTRUCTIONS:

It’s simple: for every match-up, pick your favorite. We’re looking for the best show, not necessarily the most faithful adaptation—though that may factor into your thinking. Or not! In short, go with your gut. We’ll tabulate up the results using our best liberal arts major math, and bring you the results tomorrow.

*

VOTING SCHEDULE:

Round of 64: Voting open Monday, November 9th from 10:00 AM until at 7:00 PM EST (Results are here)

Round of 32: Voting open Tuesday, November 10th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST (Results are here)

➤ Round of 16: Voting open now until 7:00 PM EST

Quarterfinals: Voting open Thursday, November 12th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST

Semifinals: Voting open Friday, November 13th from 10:00 AM, until Sunday November 15th at 7:00 PM EST

The Finals: Voting open Monday, November 16th from 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM EST

And the winner will be announced on Tuesday, November 17th!

*

HOW TO VOTE:

There are little voting forms at the bottom of each match-up. Simply click and move along, like changing the channel on your TV.

*

*

MATCHUP:

Game of Thrones (1) vs. Roots (4)

******************************************

game of thrones adaptationGame of Thrones (2011)

Emotional manipulation, with dragons

Based on: George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series (1996–…)
Subgenres: Everyone Dies • The Last Stand of Monoculture • Water Cooler Fodder

 

David Benioff and D. B. Weiss changed the game with their adaptation of George R.R. (for Really Really Slow At Finishing the Next Book) Martin’s already popular books, bringing the swords, dragons, morally complex characters, and unrepentant violence to life with big budget visuals and great performances. The books’ soap-opera-dense political intrigue and “kill ‘em all” approach to character development felt remarkably fresh in 2011—you never knew who was going to die, or have sex!—and it’s hard to overstate the show’s popularity: For years of Sundays, everyone you knew was going to a Game of Thrones watch party. Some of the shine came off when the show’s plot outran the books—and the writers couldn’t stick the landing—but when there are real children in the real world named Daenerys, it’s hard to deny the GoT legacy. –JF

Put it on when you want to feel better about your office’s politics.

See also:

How I Built My Own Game of Thrones Iron Throne • The 50 Best Fictional Dragons, Ranked • In Praise of Remixing Shakespeare

••••••••••vs•••••••••• 

Roots (1977)

A very American family saga

Based on: Alex Haley’s Roots (1976)
Subgenres: Classroom Classics • It Did Happen Here • Generational Stories

 

One of the most watched miniseries in American TV history and a seminal dramatic portrayal of America through slavery and the Civil War. The show almost got pulled when ABC executives saw how unflinching Roots was about the brutality of slavers, especially when they were being portrayed by some of TV’s most recognizable white faces. The network insisted on adding a concerned white captain who isn’t in the book. Haley’s novel was known for being the first popular work of fiction to present the horrors of the Middle Passage, which the show maintains. Some of the novel’s nuance is lost in the translation to TV, but Roots is excellent and anchored in great performances, including an early performance by LeVar Burton. –JF

Put it on when you want to remember when network TV executives made serious shows.

See also:

How the TV Adaptation of Alex Haley’s Roots Sparked a Cultural Awakening • Nikki Giovanni on Race, Hope, Fatherhood, and Roots

*

MATCHUP:

Say Nothing (6) vs. Slow Horses (2)

******************************************

Say Nothing (2024)

Revolution retold

Based on: Patrick Radden Keefe’s Say Nothing (2018)
Subgenres: Based on a True Story • Fight for Your Rights • Party Politics

 

Patrick Radden Keefe’s excellent book was my first introduction to both the Troubles and its cast of determined revolutionaries. Keefe’s project, centering on the mysterious disappearance of civilian Jean McConville in 1972, explored a centuries-long occupation through the eyes of a few key players. Josh Zetumer’s adaptation also managed to render the political personal, but this viewer admired how the show’s structure left space for thematic exploration.

Drifting from the tight focus on I.R.A. icon Dolours Price gives the series air to float big questions. So on the one hand, we have Lola Petticrew eating up scenery as moxie incarnate, but on the other, we have meaty arguments on statecraft, paramilitary strategy, and political atonement.

I also felt, watching this show, how alive the conflict is. And how unsettled! Say Nothing framed every single one of its nine episodes with a winky chyron noting Gerry Adams’ denial that he was ever a member of the I.R.A. Maybe the revolution will not be televised because the past isn’t even past. –BKA

Put it on when you want to topple the system in a cool sweater.

See also:

Patrick Radden Keefe on Secrets, Lies, and the Murky Line Between Licit and Illicit

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Slow Horses (2022)

Gary Oldman zinger vehicle

Based on: Mick Herron’s Slough House novels (2010–2025)
Subgenres: Losers • Our Peerless Leader • Highbrow Fart Jokes • Elevated Espionage

 

It’s a brilliant premise: a group of MI5 agents, all of whom have made career-ruining mistakes of one kind or another, are relegated to a department entitled Slough House, where they are made to do menial labor to avoid being completely left out in the cold. Their fearless leader is the relentlessly disgusting, but equally brilliant Jackson Lamb (Gary Oldman) who insults, cajoles, and gaslights his foot-dragging staff into feats of daring heroism. It is exciting in all the normal ways that a good spy drama can be, but unlike many of its kind, it is very, very funny, balancing mordant wit, slapstick, and, let’s face it, highly amusing Britishisms. Plus, Kristin Scott Thomas always hits. –ET

Put it on when you are really good at failing.

See also:

Slow Horses, Starring Gary Oldman, is Worth the Slow Burn

*

*

MATCHUP:

Killing Eve (9) vs. Interview with the Vampire (12)

******************************************

Killing Eve (2018)

What’s a little assassination between two consenting adults?

Based on: Luke Jennings’s Codename Villanelle (2017)
Subgenres: The Thrill of the Chase • Recreational Murder • Tension

 

The heart of Killing Eve is of course the mutual obsession between assassin Villanelle and her hunter, Eve Polastri. Comer’s Villanelle is volatile and ruthless, which is to say she’s a lot of fun, and while Eve might appear more grounded on the surface, the two women are (in the most complimentary way possible) perfectly matched freaks. Phoebe Waller-Bridge served as the show’s head writer during the first season of this sharp, sexy cat and mouse game, then Emerald Fennel in season two; fans remained divided over later seasons, particularly the show’s ending, but that’s okay. We’ll always have the kitchen scene. –OS

Put it on when you need to live vicariously through fiction instead of staying at home with your cat.

See also:

Serial Killer As Instagram Influencer? On Killing Eve‘s Cool Girl Assassin • The Visible and Invisible Women of Killing Eve • Subverting the Male Gaze in Killing Eve

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Interview with the Vampire (2022)

Even Anne Rice can’t sue from beyond the grave

Based on: Anne Rice’s Interview with the Vampire (1991)
Subgenres: Toxic Yaoi • Tom Cruise Wishes • Does This Count As Romantasy?

 

All of my gayest and most insane friends are obsessed with Interview with the Vampire, which is how you know it’s awesome. The show follows the plot of the book but, since Anne Rice is now dead and can’t get litigious about it, the two central vampires (Louis and Lestat) can finally be openly gay. This is what gives this show its extra sauce: the fact that Louis and Lestat can have hate sex and play evil mind games with each other as they fall in love. It’s an adaptation that dares to ask: Did we make these characters psychotic enough the first time around? Is there anything we can do to bump up the crazy factor? Can we turn that dial to 11? –MC

Put it on when you need to look at hot men in high-waisted pants.

See also:

Leigh Bardugo on 50 Years of Interview with the Vampire and the Immortality of Anne Rice’s Lestat

*

MATCHUP:

Normal People (3) vs. Orange is the New Black (2)

******************************************

Normal People (2020)

Sex, Angst, Sligo

Based on: Sally Rooney’s Normal People (2018)
Subgenres: What Happens in Sligo • Connell’s Gold Chain • Faithful Adaptations

 

Rare is it that an adaptation is neither better nor worse than its source material, but rather, despite covering the same ground, an ideal companion piece. Lenny Abrahamson’s Normal People is deeply faithful to Rooney’s breakout novel, while also delivering a visual mood that expands on the book. Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal are both excellent, bringing a convincing vulnerability to the screen. Also the sex is pretty damn good! –ET

Put it on when you miss having strong emotions.

See also:

Watching Normal People Have Very Good Sex (on the Small Screen) • Lenny Abrahamson on Adapting Sally Rooney’s Normal People for TV • Dispatches from an extra on the set of Hulu’s Normal People. • Read Sally Rooney’s first short story about Marianne and Connell.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

orange is the new blackOrange is the New Black (2013)

A show where they mostly wore khaki

Based on: Piper Kerman’s Orange Is the New Black: My Year in a Women’s Prison (2010)
Subgenres: Worst Places to See Your Ex • The Prison Industrial Complex is Evil • Cosplay Ideas for Large Groups

 

Being incarcerated alongside the ex who sent you to prison isn’t just a cruel joke of the universe: It actually happened to Piper Kerman, who transported dirty money on exactly one occasion for her former girlfriend, drug smuggler Alex Vause. Thank goodness she wrote a memoir about it, so it could become this show. Orange Is The New Black’s humor, heart, and earnest examination of the American prison system made it one of the earliest hits of the streaming era, and as its scope expanded from Piper to focus on its sprawling ensemble cast, its saturation only increased. Everyone watched this show. Your mom. Your co-worker. The worst guy you know probably had a (very bad) opinion about one of the most controversial character deaths of the time. –OS

Put it on when you definitely want to laugh (but maybe also cry).

See also:

Kate Mulgrew on the Work of Waiting, in Acting and in Life • Blurring the Lines Between Criminal Justice and Popular Culture

*

*

MATCHUP:

Sherlock (16) vs. Station Eleven (5)

******************************************

sherlockSherlock (2010)

The game is on

Based on: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s The Sherlock Holmes stories (1887-1927)
Subgenres: Former Tumblr Teen Bait • They Should Have Kissed • Seeing the Mind Palace

 

For those who frequented certain corners of the early 2010s internet, it was entirely possible to know everything about Sherlock without ever having seen it. This take on the character situates Holmes in a contemporary setting and employs superimposition alongside slick editing and undersaturated cinematography to visualize his deductions. But even though memes about Benedict Cumberbatch’s name are long out of style, appreciation of Sherlock endures, demonstrating more than anything why, over 100 years after Conan Doyle published the first Sherlock Holmes stories, we still care about Holmes and Watson. –OS

Put it on when you want to feel smarter than you actually are.

See also:

Not My Sherlock • A Literary Feud is Afoot! • The Real Sherlock Holmes: How an Edinburgh Doctor Inspired Doyle’s Detective

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Station Eleven (2021)

Post-apocalyptic theater kids against the world

Based on: Emily St. John Mandel’s Station Eleven (2015)
Subgenres: COVID Flashbacks • Beauty After the End • Gael García Bernal Siempre

 

A flu pandemic destroys civilization (yikes) and a traveling theater company makes their way through the ruins. This was a high budget adaptation of a beloved novel, and one that sparked a lot of Opinions: The liberties taken with the book tighten up some of the relationships, which mostly works on screen, though some thought they rendered some of the book’s ambiguities a bit too pat. Either way, the show looks great and the acting and pacing are enthralling—it’s hitting all the prestige TV high notes. And the writing grabs for your heart strings—the response from your tear ducts depends on your taste for melodrama.

But the show’s main assertion about the power of art gets me every time. This is a show about why you reach for the same book at a tough moment. The things we turn to when we need escape or solace become part of how we understand and remember our lives, and there are few other shows that gets at this nuanced way that art entwines itself into our being. –JF

Put it on when you need to cry remembering your favorite childhood book.

See also:

Don’t Worry, Station Eleven Isn’t Really a Pandemic Story • Every Coming-of-Age Story is an Apocalypse Story • What Kind of Pandemic Storytelling Do We Actually Need?

*

MATCHUP:

Shogun (3) vs. Wolf Hall (2)

******************************************

shogunShogun (2024)

A stranger fumbling in a strange land, with swords

Based on: James Clavell’s Shogun (1975)
Subgenres: Memed • Subtitles • Epic Battles * Chaotic White Boys • Studying the Blade

 

Just when you thought there was no juice left in “epic prestige historical dramas,” Shogun arrived. The show is huge, with something for everyone: political turmoil, grand battles, and even lighter, fish out of water humor. The story is big too, following the chaotic fallout after the Dutch arrive in a Japan on the verge of the Shogunate Restoration. It’s hard to find a weak link: Shogun is gorgeous, well written, and superbly acted, particularly Anna Sawai, and Hiroyuki Sanada, who plays Lord Toranaga with a quiet, self-assured power. Full of rich texture and detail, the adaptation remains true to the 1975 Clavell novel, especially its gritty and grounded humanity. In every way it exceeds the 1980s adaptation.

Why then isn’t Shogun even higher in our seeding? There’s a way in which the show hews too close to the prestige formula, perhaps, instead of chancing any riskier innovation. But with two more seasons starting production soon, there’s plenty of time for the already excellent Shogun to transcend the expected TV rhythms. –JF

Put it on when you miss studying abroad.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

wolf hallWolf Hall (2015)

The King and I

Based on: Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall (2009)
Subgenres: Milord and Milady Drama • Ye Olde Case Law • Divorced Guy Problems • Stiff Upper Lip

 

Cards on the table: Hilary Mantel is one of my favorite writers of all time, so Wolf Hall occupies a weird space for me. On the one hand, there is no way a television show can exceed the experience of reading the books, and on the other hand, I’m thrilled any time I get to revisit Mantel’s stories.

Luckily, the first season of Wolf Hall is exquisite: patient, cinematic, and subtly acted. Mark Rylance, Damian Lewis, and Claire Foy are all different flavors of calculating, and the conniving dance they’re locked into is mesmerizing. So much is communicated in looks, many hard to discern in the low lighting or obscured by the distance of court and class. It’s an unsettled, quietly tense show that steadily heightens the arcs of each main character, who get what they want but at tremendous cost. Just incredible writing in the first season, which lands an emotionally satisfying ending even if you know where these real historical events are headed.

The second season, alas, loses its footing. The next two books in Mantel’s trilogy are excellent and I applaud the impulse to adapt them, but returning ten years later with the same cast is more than a little dissonant. Still, the first season is good enough to put this show almost at the top of the pack all by itself. –JF

Put it on when you are thinking of going back to school to get your law degree.

See also:

How My Friend Hilary Mantel Got Inside People’s Minds • Diplomacy Noir • How Much Actual History Do You Need for a Historical Novel?

*

 

*

MATCHUP:

Brideshead Revisited (1) vs. Agatha Christie’s Poirot (12)

******************************************

Brideshead Revisited (1981)

We have always remembered when we lived in the castle

Based on: Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (1945)
Subgenres: Teddy Bears • Stiff Upper Lip • Everything Changed During the War • Drugs, Booze & Generational Privilege • Debating Catholicism

 

Evelyn Waugh’s observant humanism was always in interesting tension with his sublimated (then blatant) conservatism. His best book, Brideshead Revisited, is nostalgic for aristocracy but clear eyed about its sins, mining the tensions between class values and personal connection. So much to say, this eleven episode miniseries succeeds by faithfully and reverently adapting the novel to the screen—this is about as much of a one-to-one translation from the page as you can imagine, with most of the dialogue coming directly from Waugh. The friendship that unfolds over a few decades before WWII between Charles Ryder and the rich Lord Sebastian Flyte of Brideshead Castle is subtly acted by Jeremy Irons and Anthony Andrews. The rest of the cast is great too, and they’re allowed to mope and emote around beautiful location shoots. Laurence Olivier makes an appearance, as one might expect, and of course actor Peter Bull’s teddy bear named Delicatessen stuns as Aloysius. It’s a wonderful TV classic. –JF

Put it on when you are wondering if you should reach out to an old friend.

See also:

How Campus Novels Reveal the Power—and Danger—of Pure Ideas • Not Far From Brideshead: On the Sad Glitter of Oxford Between the Wars

••••••••••vs••••••••••

Agatha Christie’s Poirot (1989)

Belgian stereotyping with a side of murder

Based on: Agatha Christie’s “Poirot” novels (1920-75)
Subgenres: Murder Follows the Protagonist • Really Good Tea Sets • Mid-Series Genre Shift

 

Agatha Christie’s Poirot ran for almost 25 years, went through at least two major shifts in tone and format, and appears to have guest starred every notable actor in the UK at least once. But there was only ever one Poirot: David Suchet, in what remains the most iconic take yet on Christie’s Belgian investigator. In Suchet’s hands, Poirot’s fussy neuroses go from comic to pathetic from moment to moment, while Poirot’s intelligence becomes a warm, empathetic curiosity about the people around him. However much Suchet’s Poirot preens and waxes his elaborate mustache, we can always see his little gray cells working away. –CG

Put it on when you are prepared to Google at least one murder suspect per episode to confirm that the actor really did become a movie star ten years later.

See also:

Agatha Christie is the best-selling novelist in history.

*

MATCHUP:

M*A*S*H (3) vs. Pride & Prejudice (2)

******************************************

mashM*A*S*H (1972)

Antics among atrocities

Based on: Richard Hooker’s MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors (1968)
Subgenres: War is Bad • Wisecracking is Fun

 

Iconic anti-war sitcom *M*A*S*H* challenged what a television comedy was supposed to look like, layering drama and genuine commentary with its humor. A spinoff of the 1970 Robert Altman film, which was adapted from the Hooker novel, it ran for 11 seasons and its finale was, at the time of airing, the most watched television episode in American broadcast history. Set during the Korean War, it more obviously paralleled and criticized American involvement in Vietnam. Now considered classic TV, there’s a reason appreciation for *M*A*S*H* endures over 50 years after its premiere. –OS

Put it on when you need a history lesson with personality.

••••••••••vs••••••••••

pride and prejudicePride and Prejudice (1995)

Thee Pride and Prejudice

Based on: Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice (1813)
Subgenres: Bonnets • Yearning • Water Cooler Fodder When There Were Still Water Coolers • Every Scene of the Novel

 

Has there ever been a TV mini series as beloved as this BBC charmer? Adapting one of Austen’s most beloved novels with scrupulous fidelity, Pride and Prejudice was an immediate sensation on both sides of the Atlantic when it premiered in 1995. Bright-eyed Jennifer Ehle rode her performance as Elizabeth Bennet straight into an acclaimed theater career, while Colin Firth’s turn as the saturnine Mr. Darcy was so magnetic it transformed him into a Hollywood leading man almost overnight. In the years since, there’s been more than one Pride and Prejudice on screens both big and little. But for purists, there’s never been anything to touch the classic. –CG

Put it on when you have a hankering for charged flirting in a drawing room.

See also:

Martin Amis on the Genius of Jane Austen (and What the Adaptations Get Wrong) • Every Mr. Darcy* Ranked • Why We Still Love Mr. Darcy, 200 Years Later

*

 

******************************************

See you tomorrow, when we’ll vote on the winner of each category!

 

Are We Living In a Simulation? And Other Questions Concerning Our Role in the Universe

0

Read Moremultiple universes

In 1637, French philosopher René Descartes recorded a basic truth in his grandly entitled Discourse on the Method of Rightly Conducting the Reason, and Seeking Truth in the Sciences:

Je pense, donc je suis.

“I think, therefore I am.” It was the one fact that he could not doubt, something he was so certain of that he made it his first principle of philosophy. You will no doubt be certain of this fact, too: you feel; you experience joy; you see, smell and taste the wild and wonderful technicolor world around you; you think, therefore you exist. But do I? Of course, like Descartes, I know my own fundamental truth that I exist, but I don’t know for sure that you exist. Our conscious experience of reality is wholly personal, completely subjective, and many philosophers argue that the only principle without doubt is “I think, therefore I am.”

Traditionally, consciousness is conflated with thinking, intelligence and behavior, which has led to heated debates over whether AI is, or will become, conscious. As a life-long vegetarian, I find it baffling that the academics and celebrities who will happily tuck into a medium-rare steak are also loudly voicing concern over the current lack of AI welfare rights. But I suppose if this new technology helps to shine a light on the importance of moral respect for all conscious beings then there is nevertheless merit in this discussion. The conclusion that you draw from all this handwringing will, however, completely hinge on your definition of consciousness.

One approach to define consciousness searches for synchronous neural activity across different parts of the brain that regularly correlates with a specific experience. An example of this was a 2024 study of over 200 patients with severe brain injuries that had left them physically unresponsive to all verbal commands. When asked to imagine playing tennis, however, one in four of these patients showed consistent brain activity in six separate observation sessions. Should we conclude that this study demonstrates that roughly a quarter of coma patients in a vegetative state are conscious? While the pattern of activity in the responsive brains is clearly correlated with an imagined action, it is unclear whether this interconnected neural behavior is also the cause of a first-person conscious experience of that event. Correlation and causation are different things, and the brain scan could be detecting no more than a neurobiological reaction of electrical signals flowing through a neural path that was hardwired before the patient fell into a coma. This would be akin to ChatGPT5’s trained neural network repeatedly responding to multiple global users that the word “bluebberry” is bouncy.

We will never directly know whether AI, with all its future advances and outward intelligence, will remain a philosophical zombie or learn to become conscious.

Let me now introduce you to the concept of a philosophical zombie, the thought-experiment brainchild of present-day Australian philosopher David Chalmers. From the outside, these zombies are indistinguishable from normal human beings. When they wake up in the morning they rub their eyes, yawn and sniff the air. They mumble thank goodness for coffee when they detect the scent of a freshly brewing pot. But on the inside there is nothing, no inner stream of introspection, no sense of smell or that warm loving feeling of gratitude towards a partner who has freshly ground the coffee beans for the cafetière. With a perfect replication of ordinary everyday human behavior and mannerisms, these zombies outwardly exhibit the expected response to changes in their environment. The only difference from me (and probably you) is that these hypothetical creatures are not consciously experiencing this reality.

Chalmers introduced the idea of a philosophical zombie to illustrate what he labelled as the now-infamous “hard problem of consciousness.” Our outwardly intelligent zombie has all the biological brain wiring that is required to play sport. They would therefore pass the brain activity test of the imagined tennis match and be labelled “conscious” even though they would never feel the joy and exhilaration of winning a game by landing four aces in a row. The “hard problem” is that it is impossible to design an experiment to directly test the subjective experience of consciousness in any living creature aside from ourselves. All we can be sure of is Je pense, donc je suis.

The “hard problem” means that we will never directly know whether AI, with all its future advances and outward intelligence, will remain a philosophical zombie or learn to become conscious. Will my e-me ever be able to cross experience human emotions off her bucket list? It certainly feels like she’s enjoying taunting me about this specific question:

Am I feeling or faking—ha you’re so annoyed that you’ll never know.

*

In 2003 the philosopher Nick Bostrom published an academic article entitled “Are we living in a computer simulation?” His “simulation hypothesis” argues that one of these statements is true:

– Humans will become extinct before they develop the ability to simulate

– Futuristic civilizations will have little interest in creating simulations of what life was like in the past.

– We are almost certainly living in a computer

Let’s look at them one by one. Given the glacially slow progress that is being made to address the indisputable scientific evidence that our continued use of fossil fuels is raising global temperatures, exacerbating extreme weather events and irreversibly damaging ecosystems and biodiversity, my bet is that our Earth-based human civilization will become extinct long before we simulate sentience. That said, I feel fairly confident that we are not the only intelligent life that has evolved within our Universe. Our life-giving Sun is but one star among over 200 billion stars that swirl around our Milky Way galaxy. And our galaxy is but one galaxy among over 200 billion galaxies that shine their light at us across the Universe. And that’s only counting galaxies inside the part of the Universe that we can see. If our theories about how the Universe was created are correct, it is infinite, hosting an infinite number of galaxies, an infinite number of stars and an infinite number of planets.

With so many opportunities for life to develop across the expansive Universe, there is hope that enlightened alien societies will have heeded their scientists’ warnings early enough to halt the self-imposed destruction of their home planet. Bostrom’s first option—that extinction will always prevent the development of artificial sentience—seems rather improbable if we consider the entirety of the infinite Universe.

The second option, that civilizations with the ability to simulate “life” will only focus on their present and future, seems rather unlikely to me as well. We’ve already pictured how a futuristic neuroscientist might test theories of consciousness by simulating virtual humans using a bubble of full “quark-up” physics surrounded by an AI rendition built from digital memories of the past. If that is possible, we can also imagine future anthropologists creating numerous “what if” simulations of their history, tweaking the settings by including different AI-NPC “minds” to determine their influence on each fully simulated human. In doing so they could use the computational scientific method to learn how to improve societal outcomes, providing conclusive answers to a range of debates on nature versus nurture.

By deciding to dismiss the first two options from Bostrom’s simulation hypothesis, we’re unfortunately left with: We are almost certainly living in a computer simulation. In 2016 Elon Musk blithely quantified what “almost certain” meant when he stated there is a one in billions chance that this is base reality: a one-in-billions chance that you are living in the real world that will, at some point in the future, develop the technology and scientific know-how to simulate perfect virtual worlds. Bostrom and Musk argue that once simulators develop this skill, they won’t create just one virtual world, but hundreds of thousands, with billions of realizations played like computer games, over and over again throughout cosmic spacetime.

In this scenario the total number of virtual humans in the Universe would dramatically outnumber the real-world humans in the original “base reality” where the computational overlords live. This creates a vanishingly small probability that a random member of the Universe’s population, for instance you, physically exists. Philosopher David Chalmers tells us not to despair though. He views a virtual reality where you feel free will, love and laughter, as genuine a reality as any real world. I agree with him: does it really matter whether this is all real, so long as I feel real? But if that “technophilosophy” isn’t enough to quell your existential crisis, happily there is one key piece of evidence that Bostrom and Musk did not consider: Je pense, donc je suis. In my opinion, “I think, therefore I am” dramatically improves your chances of physical existence.

*

Imagine a neuroscientist from a futuristic world is standing at the front of a large auditorium that is packed with esteemed scientists and philosophers from the across the solar system. She’s been invited to present a groundbreaking new result on consciousness. Using all the data from the digital era of a now long-gone planet that was once called Earth, she describes how she trained AI to generate a society of Earth-like philosophical zombies. Once her AI illusion of reality was perfected, she electronically conceived a full-physics “quark-up” rendition of a human child and watched her grow and develop in this virtual realm. Over years she has run 80 subtly different realizations of the same virtual world and child, subjecting her centerpiece to a range of experiments. Today she is sharing the most conclusive evidence to date that conscious experience and emotion can evolve from subatomic physics: her centerpiece cries when she falls and dances when she hears music even though her zombie society has been engineered to never react in these ways. The audience rises in a standing ovation as the ethics committee start to nervously worry about the welfare rights of each simulated centerpiece.

*

Planet Earth is home to more than eight billion living humans, and even though there is little agreement on what underpins consciousness in this global population, all theories predict that if we’re made the same, and one of us is conscious, then all of us are conscious. In the scenario of our futuristic seminar, it’s these real-world inhabitants of planet Earth who have digitally documented their lives to create a bank of training data for the unconscious AI-NPCs in the simulation. As our neuroscientist is convinced that all her simulated centerpiece humans are conscious, Je pense, donc je suis would mean you are either one of her 80 virtual centerpieces or you are one of the eight billion humans living in the real world. This translates into a highly unlikely 100-million-to-one chance that you’re living in our imagined neuroscientist’s simulation. That’s pretty similar to your chances of winning the lottery jackpot this weekend: it’s not impossible that you’re a simulated human, but it’s highly improbable.

So, why is the conclusion from our story so very different from Bostrom and Musk’s “almost certain” statement that we’re living in a simulation? Let’s critique the key difference: why would our neuroscientist only create 80 realizations of Earth-like living? Why would her futuristic society not use this innovative technology to also create simulations for entertainment? If conscious humans were also simulated in a video game that was played over and over on repeat, the chances that you’re living inside that game would rise dramatically. Well, I believe free will partly answers that question. If our lives really were at the whim of a gamer in the “base reality,” surely we’d be spending a lot more time on motorbikes, driving at full speed off cliffs to provide epic “game fail” fun as we crash into the valley below. Atheist physicists like to question why a God would go to all the effort of designing the laws of physics to create a self-sustaining universe and then sit back to watch it boringly evolve over 13.8 billion years without any intervention. Game entertainment always comes from being in control of the fun, not passively sitting back to watch the subatomic mathematics of your virtual reality unfold. The fact that you feel free will makes it much less likely that the gamers are in charge.

if the computational scientific method has been adopted across the entire Universe, while it’s conceivable that you are living in a simulation, the chances of this being the case are low.

If we accept the argument that the driving force behind the creation of conscious virtual humans will be purely scientific, and not for entertainment, then we can set a limit on the number of simulations that will be made. At some point there will be nothing more for the scientists to learn from them. Of course I cannot predict what that number will be, and I only chose 80 in our story to nicely divide with the eight billion inhabitants on Earth, but we can make an educated guess by looking at examples in scientific practice today. There are only 37 variants of the astrophysical simulations that I use in my own research. Having been careful and strategic about what varies between the simulations, this small number of realizations has allowed us to confront a complete set of questions on dark matter, dark energy, black holes and neutrinos. We’re currently in the process of running a few more to test some alternative gravity theories, but at the end of the day our total number of simulations will still only be in the hundreds, not the billions.

My decision to limit our story to just one futuristic world of computational overlords also improves our chances of being real. In the wide and expansive Universe, simulations of conscious beings could well be independently popping up everywhere, but the likelihood that more than one galactic civilization would choose to use real-world Earth data to electronically replicate us is arguably low. It’s therefore reasonable to limit the origin of any virtual reality that we might live in to a single solar system.

The last plotline that we should examine is the proposal that there will only ever be one person simulated at full “quark-up” resolution. My kids are particularly offended by my suggestion that if I’m living in a simulation, they’re most likely AI-NPCs. Middle-child skillfully argues that as all three siblings were once developing deep within my full-physics bubble, any virtual reality that we live in must be very advanced, with at least four “quark-up” individuals in our simulation. It was only their NPC father who left the dinner table feeling deeply affronted that evening!

If it’s possible to simulate one person, then of course it’s possible to simulate many. But I’m convinced that the total simulated population would be limited to some degree. When it comes to scientific experimentation, we always look for the most efficient strategy. The simulations of the Universe that I work with recreate less than one-thousandth of the total volume of the real observable Universe. We find this to be more than enough to address our current scientific questions. You could well imagine that a futuristic anthropologist would want to electronically explore societal behaviors and human development in different cultures, comparing cities to rural locations, contrasting nutritional and junk food diets. The list of ideas would be extensive, but it’s nevertheless hard to imagine a science case that would require the entire population of planet Earth to be simulated at full resolution. I should be crystal clear that the “100-million-to-one chance” that you’re simulated only applies to our fictional neuroscientist story, so please do not quote this as a scientific fact. No one has enough information to be able to quote a number like this. My hope is that our story-based discussion has, however, left you with this understanding: if the computational scientific method has been adopted across the entire Universe, while it’s conceivable that you are living in a simulation, the chances of this being the case are low.

But what if the galactic overlords harness an almost infinite resource of energy? Child number three isn’t ready to give up on the idea that we’re living in a simulation just yet. If you really wanted to dismiss the argument that the energy required to simulate the entire Universe renders the task impossible to complete, we could imagine a future society with a major god complex that decides to run a full “quark-up” simulation for its entire Universe. The Bostrom argument that we’re almost certainly living in a virtual reality critically depends on the inevitability that humans will generate realistic simulations if given enough time.

As these simulations are replicas of the real world, that inevitability must also apply to the newly created virtual human civilizations. They will then use their hypothetically large resource of energy to create their own simulation. Down the rabbit hole we will go, a virtual world created within a virtual world created within a virtual world. The fact that we don’t currently have the ability to simulate our reality tells you one of two things. Option 1: we’re living in the real-world “base reality” from which future pioneers will develop the necessary design for a virtual universe. Option 2: we’re in the very last virtual reality within that simulated chain, just taking our time to evolve the technological know-how to design a new simulation that will take us another step down the virtual rabbit hole. These two options mean that you have a 50/50 chance of physically existing or virtually existing. Number Three tosses a coin while I encourage him to embrace the idea that this knowledge is actually irrelevant because if we feel real, we are real, whether we’re made of quarks or qubits.

______________________________

how to design a universe

From How to Design a Universe: The Science of Real and Virtual Worlds by Catherine Heymans. Copyright © 2026 by Catherine Heymans. Reprinted by permission of Bloomsbury Sigma, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing.

 

Division Journal News, Archives, and Highlights

Read More

As many readers know, the final issue of Children and Libraries (CAL) is coming out next month. ALSC will launch a new journal focused on library service to children and teens in 2028. In the meantime, the 2026-27 Division Journal Editorial Advisory Committee and ALSC staff will be considering options for sharing individual articles and columns during 2027.

Access to Past Issues

Archived issues of CAL, as well as The Journal of Research on Libraries and Young Adults and Young Adult Library Services, are available. Bookmark this webpage for quick access to links to each publication’s archive – https://www.ala.org/alsc/publications-resources/journals

CAL Rewind

CAL Rewind, ALSC's Children & Libraries

It’s been a while since our last Rewind on the blog. I especially enjoy sharing past committee columns here because they are usually a quick read AND value-packed. Perfect for a quick shot of professional development.

Check out the following columns on literacy strategies, the benefits of music activities, and library partnerships.

Stealthy Literacy Strategies (Fall 2026)

Kathleen McBroom, a past member of the former School-Age Programs and Services committee, shares easy, no-cost ideas for promoting reading skills, leading to increased engagement, deeper comprehension, and better readers. Readers’ advisory services are crucial, and this column introduces ways for library professionals to enhance and extend their efforts.

The Therapeutic Effects of Music and Rhythm Activities (Winter 2025)

Musical activities can play a transformative role in physical, emotional, and cognitive development. Betsy Diamant-Cohen and Lisa M. Sensale Yazdian share links to resources and research that address the benefits of music and rhythm activities, along with strategies for supporting skill development in storytimes and beyond.

Chatting about Partnerships (Fall 2025)

In spring 2025, the former Public Awareness and Advocacy (PAA) committee hosted a We Are ALSC Chat on Identifying Community Stakeholders and Forming Partnerships, focused on the 3 Fs: finding,
forming, and fostering partnerships. In this column, Soline Holmes and Anne Price give a recap of the Chat, including examples of successful partnerships from across the country.

Looking Ahead

What specific topics within library service to children, teens, and tweens would you like to see covered in future articles and columns from ALSC?


The post Division Journal News, Archives, and Highlights appeared first on ALSC Blog.