Civil Discourse with Joyce Vance
Calling Institutions Broken When They Aren’t
Essay Three: The Republic, Revisited.
By Joyce Vance, 4 hours ago (October 28, 2026
This is the third in a series of ten essays revisiting my book, Giving Up Is Unforgivable: A Manual For Keeping A Democracy, which was released a year ago. I reread it recently, wanting to see how my assessment held up, and was surprised (and happy) about how vital it still feels today. I wrote about my goals for this series of essays here. If you’re just finding Civil Discourse through The Republic, Revisited essays, I hope you’ll subscribe—it’s free—and read along with us.
Donald Trump is a destroyer of institutions. At this point, that’s plain. And while his hardcore base embraces and celebrates the destruction, most of us understand how essential the basic institutions are as the architecture to support our democracy. This week, with the elections upon us, I wanted to revisit a part of the book where I discuss our democratic institutions. They are a quirky thing, fueled by our confidence in them. To work, we have to use them, defend them, improve them, and, most importantly, populate them with competent people committed to public service.
Donald Trump knows that the surest way to break our democratic institutions is to claim they’re already broken. DOGE was just the beginning. Today, it’s overt attacks on “fake” news, our elections, civil rights groups, judges who rule against him even if they’re his own appointees—pretty much anyone involved in an institution with the ability to stand in his way.
His narrative of broken institutions has gained a lot of traction among people who don’t think this through. We need to be discerning before accepting the view that the institutions are broken. Yes, some of them have taken damage, and many are stretched thin. Trump himself is responsible for much of that. But when you look more closely, there are signs that, despite what they’ve been through, they remain resilient. They can be restored and, perhaps more importantly, revitalized when our time comes. As they continue to face difficulties imposed by the president, they deserve our support.
In the book, I wrote that our institutions “have not been irredeemably broken as some would have us believe.” I still believe that’s true and that our support for them now is even more important than it was in the spring of 2025 when I wrote those words.
“In the popular myth, Donald Trump is invincible. But that’s a myth, not reality. Every would-be authoritarian in history has tried to assume the mantle of inevitability.
But here’s an essential, often overlooked truth about the United States: In significant ways, both big and small, it has subtle advantages when it comes to retaining democracy, chief among them its institutions. Even under stress, they can be nimble. They can take on new challenges, just as we did during and after the Civil War, through two world wars, during the Depression, in the aftermath of Watergate, and following 9/11. They evolve, they have reach.
And beyond the three formal branches of government, there is an informal fourth one, the press. These institutions are populated by individuals with a deep commitment to democracy, the career civil service. And beyond them there are civil society groups, the military, lawyers, unions, students, and teachers, each with their own commitments to ensuring the continuation of democracy. Our voting infrastructure is decentralized—we hold fifty state elections, not one federal one—so no one person can take control of it. Those state elections are usually run at the county level by everyday Americans.
We are a democracy with almost 250 years of history behind us. We have democracy at the federal level, but also at the state and local levels. We order our society in a democratic fashion so deeply ingrained that although we have fallen into the habit of taking it for granted, it is the substrata that our entire way of life is built upon.
Read more: Calling Institutions Broken When They Aren’t – Civil Discourse – Joyce VanceContinue/Read Original Article: Calling Institutions Broken When They Aren’t
Discover more from DrWeb's Domain
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

