The Years When Gospel Artists Went Platinum

0
9
DWD Featured Image Feb 9, 2026
DWD Featured Image Feb 9, 2026

Read Moreconcert audience

Perhaps the first time I realized the power and impact of gospel music, I was no more than six years old. I woke up in the middle of the night for some reason. All was dark and quiet except for the music coming from the clock radio that my mother kept on the kitchen counter. When I was little, the carpet covering the threshold of my bedroom door used to scare me so badly that I would not want to leave my room at night. When the bedroom was dark and the hallway’s light hit the threshold, the otherwise beige carpet would look like a dark and stormy sea of Texas-sized bugs to my young eyes—impenetrable. But, that night, it was too dark for me to see imagined critters, and the music was too beautiful. That night, I left my bedroom and walked down the hallway until I was inches from the radio. As the perennial 12:00 midnight flashed red (as the time on the clock needed to be set), Andraé Crouch and his singing compatriots belted:

We need to hear from you
We need a word from you
If we don’t hear from you
What will we do?

And, in that cozy two-bedroom apartment on the southwest side of Houston, Texas, while my family slept, I stood captivated as the gospel sounds washed over me. This memory of hearing that song play on the kitchen clock radio remains a poignant one for me. It marks the beginning of my enduring relationship with gospel music.

Gospel music reached an apex of creativity and commercial success in a period I call the Platinum Age of Gospel. During gospel’s Golden Age, spanning from 1945 to 1965 or as late as 1980, the gospel industry focused on creating music for churchgoers as gospel became ubiquitous in Black churches, and a handful of gospel artists found success crossing over to mainstream audiences. The Platinum Age, from 1993 to 2013, is the consequential era when the gospel industry’s focus on crossover music changed everything—from the way Black churches engaged in worship to how artists reimagined their music, ministries, and personas. During the twenty-year period of the Platinum Age, twenty-six different Black gospel recordings achieved platinum sales, or sales of at least one million units—a staggering feat for the gospel industry.

In the Platinum Age, gospel artists wanted to bring attention to their bodies and to their own ownership and display of sexuality.

My book, The Platinum Age of Gospel: The Years When Crossover Music Changed Everything, is an open letter to the gospel industry—a love letter and an official complaint at the same time. It celebrates what is magnificent about contemporary crossover gospel music of the 1990s and 2000s, while also calling for more critical reflection on how the music industry affects the way people learn and experience Christianity through music it promotes and helps make available to local churches and individual consumers.

*

One brisk school night, years ago, I am sitting in a small classroom in Adams House, a Harvard College dorm for undergraduates beyond their first year. As a PhD student and resident tutor at Adams House back then, I am on call, responsible for patrolling the halls periodically through the night. As I wait to do my second set of rounds for the night, I sit and chat with another resident tutor and a college senior. It is my turn to share, so I unlock my phone and pull up a YouTube video of Platinum Age gospel artist Kirk Franklin directing his band of singers and musicians through “He Reigns,” Franklin’s Latin-tinged, upbeat remake of “Awesome God,” which he released on his Rebirth of Kirk Franklin (Live) album in 2002.

The video of Kirk Franklin I mention was apparently recorded at one of his Hopeville Tour concert stops in Austin, Texas. His short frame is draped in an oversized, blouse-like white shirt that partially covers a pair of dark leather pants. As the singers end their unison refrain, Franklin invites the audience to dance with him as they would “at a club,” declaring that Christians are free to do so. Franklin begins to demonstrate some dance moves that appear to be inspired by soul singer James Brown.

As we huddle around my cell phone, the college senior attentively watches the phenomenon that is Kirk Franklin in concert. In so doing, she makes no mention of the bubbly arrangement of “He Reigns.” She does not discuss the alternation between unison female voices and three-part vocal harmony. She utters not a word about the syncopated verses—nor a comment about the band’s ability to seamlessly move between Latin, Afro-Caribbean, and African American rhythms. The student states incredulously, “He sure does move his hips a lot.”

Her comment suggests that there is something sensual, perhaps even sexual, and not quite holy about the way Franklin moves his body. Whether one considers Franklin’s dancing as merely sensual or also sexual, his dancing does suggest a kind of attention seeking through the body or through adornment and movement unlike in any previous period of gospel music. Gospel has always been bodily, highly animated, and often misread as erotic. But in the Platinum Age, gospel artists wanted to bring attention to their bodies and to their own ownership and display of sexuality, whereas previous generations traded in carnal denial—at least on stage. Platinum Age gospel artists were meticulous about presenting themselves as sexually attractive; this was part of a larger enterprise of assimilating with contemporary heteronormative culture.

The preoccupation with appearance and sex appeal was so prevalent that the phrase sexy for Jesus was used by gospel artists to describe themselves and each other. The first time I heard a gospel artist mention this was on the short-lived 2009 television show 106 & Gospel, a gospelized version of the BET network’s popular music video show 106 & Park. The 106 & Gospel female cohost Angel Taylor, from the contemporary gospel group Trin-i-tee 5:7, referred to herself as “sexy for Jesus.” In 2014 contemporary gospel singer-songwriter BeBe Winans also stated to an interviewer for the online news outlet The Grio: “I can’t help that I’m sexy for Jesus.” The expression had been in circulation among artists for years.

To be sexy for Jesus is to bring attention to one’s own sexualized body for the purpose of Christian witness. That is, the sexy for Jesus artist attempts or is perceived to be sexually attractive, and the artist suggests that any attention gained by sex appeal is in service of evangelizing. During the Platinum Age, it was common for crossover gospel artists to operate in all things with a sexy-for-Jesus persona. Gospel artists employed sexy-for-Jesus tactics as part of their marketing and promotion strategies in pursuing relevance among black popular music consumers outside of the church—especially hip hop and R&B audiences.

The sexy-for-Jesus work was part of a larger movement for relevance among gospel artists. By the early 2000s, gospel artists had developed a sophisticated set of behaviors to render themselves relatable, accessible, or “relevant” as they would say, to mainstream audiences. Their set of crossover strategies for gaining respect and market share in a mainstream market is the performance of relevance. Performance of relevance is not synonymous with branding. A brand is what helps people (notably consumers) recognize and identify a particular company, product, or individual. Whereas the goal of a brand is to show distinction in the marketplace, performance of relevance emphasizes similitude with a popular culture.

Crossover strategies included—and were not limited to—adopting various cultural aspects of the target market, especially popular music and dance forms; style, including fashion and status symbols; language, including slang or idioms; association with mainstream artists; and conspicuous sexuality. Donning contemporary fashion not only signaled that the gospel artist was in step with the latest trends but also demonstrated aesthetic viability and competitiveness in the mainstream marketplace. Moreover, status symbols such as expensive hair extensions, apparel, cars, and homes validated the artists in a capitalist society that highly valued accrual of money and material goods.

Musicologist Cheryl Keyes likens female rappers to “daughters of the blues,” suggesting that like the 1920s blues singers such as Ma Rainey and Bessie Smith, 1990s female rappers were using their music to “contest, protest, and affirm working-class ideologies of Black womanhood.” Gospel women such as the duo Mary Mary were not just “daughters of the blues,” as female rappers were, but they were the new blues women who were also contesting, protesting, and redefining Black Protestant womanhood within American hip hop culture.

Just as 1920s blues women “reflected and helped to construct a new Black consciousness,” the Platinum Age new blues women and men—especially Mary Mary and Kirk Franklin—represented and helped redefine a Black Protestant identity that did not reject the secular, the sensual, or the heterosexual. Tina and Erica Campbell, the biological sisters who formed gospel duo Mary Mary, were not known to describe their music and ministry as womanist or feminist, although it was clear that they saw themselves as doing liberatory work by embracing their own femininity, desire, and sexual agency.

In 2013 Erica Campbell appeared in a formfitting white outfit in a promotional photograph for the title track of her first solo album, Help, which was released in 2014. She received much flak on social media for the white bodycon ensemble styled by J. Bolin; naysayers complained it was too provocative. In response to the criticism, Campbell doubled down on her declaration of her God-given sex appeal: “But I dare not feel uncomfortable with my sexuality. God created sex and sexuality. I do not believe that it has to be negative. From a Christian perspective, take ownership of how God made you and you can still be beautiful and strong and sexy, and sexy is not a bad word.”

Mary Mary’s embrace of hip hop culture was especially apparent in their 2008 single “God in Me.” In 2009 it peaked at #5 on Billboard’s Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. “God in Me” sounds similar to actor-singer-comedian Jamie Foxx’s 2008 “Blame It (On the Alcohol)” featuring hip hop and R&B artist T-Pain. Both songs share stylistic elements with the 2007 popular hip hop soul tune “Buy U A Drank” by artist T-Pain. “Buy U A Drank” is an ode to couples who met in the club. While the Marys do not set their “God in Me” video in a club, perhaps they have chosen the next best thing—a fashion show. The thumping bass line of “God in Me” creates an infectious, urban dance groove upon which gospel lyrics are layered. In “God in Me,” Mary Mary aims to convince the listener of God’s benevolence by tallying the material blessings of the song’s protagonist: She can “write checks with a whole lot of zeros” and has a nice car and fashionable clothes.

The Platinum Age gospel industry set itself on a course for the identity crisis it now faces.

In the “God in Me” fashion show, audience members include Ye (Kanye West), hip hop celebrity Derek Watkins (also known as Fonzworth Bentley), and rapper/singer CeeLo Green. The “God in Me” lyrics are sprinkled with slang terms such as “whip,” “crib,” and “tight,” rather than overt scriptural references.

The danger of such relevant performance was that artists could give more consideration to attracting and retaining consumers’ attention, than to sincere rendering of sacred music. There was a danger in trying so hard to inflect or emulate, for example, commercial hip hop culture. Gospel could cease to be a compelling alternative as it morphed into a good knockoff, at best, of mainstream popular music.

*

In his Grammy-nominated sermon “Watch Them Dogs,” Reverend Bennett Walker Smith (1933-2001) tells the story of a little dog who, while within the comfort and protection of his master’s house gate, made a lot of commotion to incite a big Doberman Pinscher who passed by every day. One day, as the little dog barked his usual noisy provocations, the gate swung open. The Doberman, seizing the opportunity to exact his revenge, swooped in and punished the little dog for his persistent harassment. Reverend Smith says that after taking a thorough pummeling from the Doberman, the little dog wiped his brow in exasperation and asked, “Who…left the gate open?”

Who left the metaphorical gospel gate open? The gospel industry left the gate open. During the Platinum Age, gospel artists and executives swung the gate wide in warm invitation to mainstream R&B, hip hop, and white Christian artists to collaborate and enter gospel markets as gospel artists entered mainstream markets. In this post-Platinum era, the gospel industry is now taking the blows as the big dogs of the mainstream markets have continued to swoop in and dominate the Billboard gospel charts and RIAA “Christian/Gospel” certifications.

Incredibly, Ye’s rap album Donda entered the Billboard’s Top Gospel Albums chart at #1 in September 2021, and at the end of July 2026 had spent 256 weeks (nearly five years) on the chart, with 163 weeks at #1—even though it does not musically, ideologically, or theologically register to most gospel enthusiasts and gospel artists as gospel music. Maverick City Music (MCM) held a top-ten spot with its contemporary worship music (CWM) album Old Church Basement, released by Elevation Worship, the CWM music publishing arm of Elevation Church.

“First of all, I want to thank God, ’cause this is a gospel award, huh?” Southern rapper GloRilla had just won the 2025 BET Dr. Bobby Jones Gospel/Inspirational Award. GloRilla won this award with “Rain Down on Me,” a song on which she had collaborated with gospel artist Kierra Sheard and gospel and Christian music standouts Kirk Franklin, Chandler Moore, and Maverick City Music choir. Kirk Franklin and gospel industry executive Norman Gyamfi joined GloRilla on stage and stood in support as she delivered her acceptance speech. She ebulliently continued: “This [is] my first BET Award even though I’ve been here three years [and was] nominated six times…Shout out to Kirk Franklin. I ain’t gonna lie; I was kind of scared to ask him for a feature on this song because y’all know how I be rapping.”

The controversy that ensued after GloRilla’s win is a striking case study of the current state of gospel industry affairs following the industry’s push toward crossover music during the Platinum Age. The Platinum Age gospel industry set itself on a course for the identity crisis it now faces: Artists from hip hop, Christian worship, and even artificial intelligence dominate gospel charts and take coveted gospel music awards.

Fortunately, some of gospel’s biggest artists are now helping to turn the industry’s attention back to gospel’s history and canon in a reclamation of gospel identity. Choir and quartet music are experiencing a revival. Among the most important post-Platinum Age developments is Kirk Franklin’s live recording of a church music album on December 6, 2025. This is his first live recording since the 2002 release of The Rebirth of Kirk Franklin album. His return to church music suggests that the ship can slowly turn in a new direction that will benefit Black churches, as well as gospel enthusiasts and gospel artists who are not aiming to cross over. As local and national artists revisit and remix old gospel classics in their respective Sunday morning worship sets and concert repertoires, they engage in what could be described as Sankofa—a term taken from the Akan people of Ghana, which signifies going back and retrieving what was forgotten. Or, as the older saints might say, folks are heeding the admonition to find “the old paths…and walk therein” (Jeremiah 6:16 King James Version).

______________________________

the platinum age of gospel

Adapted from The Platinum Age of Gospel: The Years When Crossover Music Changed Everything by Charrise Barron. Copyright © 2026. Available from Harvard University Press.

 


Discover more from DrWeb's Domain

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.